More than three decades after the 1994 killings of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman, newly unsealed federal court records have brought renewed attention to a possible lead involving Joseph “Joey” Ippolito, a convicted drug trafficker and federal informant with connections to O.J. Simpson and his longtime confidant Al Cowlings.

A report by The New York Times, based on recently unsealed court documents and interviews, details Ippolito’s cooperation with federal authorities following his recapture after escaping from a Florida federal prison in 1994. Ippolito had relocated to Southern California, where he managed an Italian restaurant in Santa Monica, and was reportedly acquainted with both Simpson and Cowlings.

A December 1996 letter from a federal prosecutor seeking leniency for Ippolito described him as a valuable source who possessed information relevant to the Simpson case, including details concerning Simpson’s purported disposal of the murder weapon, which investigators never recovered.

The records have renewed questions about whether another person may have assisted Simpson in the aftermath of the killings, although they do not independently establish that Ippolito participated in the crimes.

Ippolito’s brother, Sam, separately told The New York Times that Joey returned home on the night of the killings with what appeared to be blood on his hands and a bag containing a heavy object. Sam alleged that his brother asked him to dispose of the bag. However, Sam later attempted to retract his account after the newspaper declined his request for compensation, raising questions about the reliability of his statements.

Former lead prosecutor Marcia Clark said she had not been informed of Ippolito during the original criminal proceedings and questioned whether he had provided credible or relevant evidence. Surfacing reports suggest that federal authorities shared information concerning Ippolito with Los Angeles prosecutors as Simpson’s criminal trial was nearing its conclusion.

Simpson was acquitted of the murders in 1995 but was subsequently found liable for the wrongful deaths of Brown and Goldman in a 1997 civil trial. He died in 2024.

Malcolm LaVergne, executor of Simpson’s estate, later cautioned against “drawing definitive conclusions from renewed allegations” concerning events that the principal individuals involved can no longer address.

The Los Angeles Police Department has also confirmed that the double-homicide case remains open and ongoing. The department stated that detectives will pursue viable investigative leads if any new evidence emerges.

Keep reading