No, the UK Speech Regulator Isn’t Giving Up on Scanning Private Messages

You might have seen some fairly astonishing headlines recently, announcing that the UK’s speech regulator, Ofcom, has decided not to force companies to scan people’s phones, and that the new “safety measures” announced on November 16 are actually good news.

What Ofcom has done is update two of its Codes of Practice – the Illegal Content Codes and the Protection of Children Codes. The changes are detailed in a document published on the regulator’s website, and are set to come into force in February 2027, if Parliament approves them.

Ofcom’s “recommendations” – non-compliance with which can result in fines of up to 10 percent of a company’s annual global turnover – include using “proactive technology” to detect illegal content, and prevent children from accessing it.

They also include permanent bans for users found to have shared content that shows child abuse – and using “highly effective” age assurance to decide which accounts should have anti-grooming protections.

In the case of encrypted group chats that Ofcom wants companies to police, the regulator is aware that this “may interfere significantly with users’ privacy, in particular where lawful private communications are removed or where an incorrect illegal content judgement results in inaccurate inferences about users or disclosure of information about a user to law enforcement.”

The Record writes that the UK’s communications regulator Ofcom “does not have the power to make technology companies scan people’s personal devices for child abuse images.”

What Ofcom actually said was that it “does not have powers under the Act to regulate devices.”

While the latest Ofcom “recommendations” – or “safety measures” – don’t include client-side scanning, the regulator can still order that once it’s “accredited” a tool that does the scanning.

Section 121 of the Act allows Ofcom to give a “technology notice” to a company, ordering it to use “accredited” software to find CSAM in private messages.

Keep reading

Britain Refuses To Release Full Migrant Crime Data, Citing Offenders’ Privacy

The British government is refusing to release detailed crime statistics on foreign nationals, saying the data could reveal the identities of the offenders, Breitbart News reported.

The Centre for Migration Control, a think tank, filed Freedom of Information requests with the Ministry of Justice seeking crime figures for foreign nationals. The ministry turned them down, as first reported by the Mail on Sunday.

“On balance the interests of the data subjects to safeguard personal information outweigh the legitimate interest in this case,” the ministry said in its rejection.

Robert Bates, the group’s research director, was furious. “It is outrageous that the Government is putting the data protection rights of foreign national offenders ahead of the British public,” he said. “We have a right to know the impact mass migration is having on public safety.”

“The extraordinary lengths being taken to conceal the truth suggest the Government knows there is a major problem but is more concerned about the public finding out than taking meaningful steps to tackle migrant crime,” Bates added.

Britain does publish some figures. Foreigners accounted for 14.1 percent of sex offenses in 2025. But the data is not broken down by nationality or specific crime, making it impossible for the public to see which groups are more likely to commit offenses such as rape, child sexual abuse or murder.

The government is also fighting a ruling by the Information Commissioner ordering it to release full foreign crime statistics for England and Wales from 2018 to 2024.

An earlier analysis by The Telegraph, comparing census data with prison populations, found that foreign nationals were 27 percent more likely to be imprisoned than British citizens. Albanians were jailed at a rate of about 232 per 10,000 people, compared with 14 per 10,000 for Britons. Kosovars, Vietnamese, Algerians and Somalis were also jailed at far higher rates.

In response, the government said it has “prioritised deportation of foreign national offenders,” with nearly 12,000 removed since July 2024, and has changed the law so foreign prisoners can be deported sooner.

Keep reading

This Is State-Snooping Taken To The Extreme: UK Taxman Wants Your AI Chatbot History

The UK government’s tax collectors are pushing for powers that would let HMRC demand the private chatbot conversations ordinary Britons have with AI tools when preparing their returns.

Under proposals in the Budget Bill, the definition of what the taxman can force you to hand over expands from computer “records” to any “relevant thing.” That wording opens the door to prompt histories, working papers and full conversations on platforms such as ChatGPT, Microsoft Copilot and Claude if they played any part in calculating figures.

The measure sits inside a broader drive to close a £59 billion tax gap. Failure to respond to a Schedule 36 information notice already carries an initial £300 penalty; those who do not correct inaccuracies can be hit for up to £3,000. Third parties, including the AI companies themselves, can even be ordered to supply the data, the Telegraph reports.

HMRC insists it is merely modernizing old powers for a digital world and that requests will still need a lawful basis. Critics see the thin end of a very long wedge.

Keep reading

This Case Is Insane…

In Britain’s two-tier policing system, law-abiding citizens who try to report real dangers now risk prosecution for private mutterings inside their own vehicles, while actual criminals face little consequence.

A Glasgow father handed over dashcam footage after nearly being forced off the road, only for Police Scotland to charge him instead.

The case, detailed by Free Speech Union general secretary Toby Young in The Spectator, centers on a man referred to as Craig. He was driving his four-year-old son home to Glasgow after a day at an amusement park in Falkirk. Exiting the motorway, another vehicle cut him up, forcing him to swerve to avoid a collision. Suspecting the other driver was drunk, Craig called the police from his car. Both vehicles stopped; officers arrived, declined to breathalyze anyone, and took Craig’s dashcam footage to check for offenses.

A week later the officers returned the footage and informed him an offense had been committed – by him, not the other driver.

His “crime” was muttering the words “smelly black bastard” under his breath seconds after the near-miss.

As the article notes, the windows were closed, so no one outside the vehicle could have heard him. The other driver was not looking in his direction and could not have seen the words. The only person who might have heard was the four-year-old in the back.

Keep reading

45 Attorneys General Urgently Want Congress to Push Platforms Toward Age Checks

A bipartisan group of 45 attorneys general from 42 states, the District of Columbia, American Samoa, and the US Virgin Islands have asked Congress to pass the Senate’s Kids Online Safety Act (KOSA) censorship law, and make sure the bill’s duty of care provision is included.

The letter, sent on November 3 and announced by Hawaii on November 4, was signed by the attorneys general of these 45 US jurisdictions, led by Hawaii’s Anne Lopez, Ohio’s Andy Wilson, Tennessee’s Jonathan Skrmetti, and Connecticut’s William Tong.

The same group, although smaller by five at the time, sent a similar letter to Congress in February, when 40 attorneys general urged Congress to pass the Senate version of KOSA, again, with its duty of care in place.

We have been tracking the progress of KOSA, and explained that the duty of care makes social media platforms responsible for shielding minors from content that a regulator decides is harmful, which in reality pressures sites to censor lawful speech to avoid legal action.

As for the House version, it makes everyone, regardless of age, prove it to social media companies.

The letter now makes the case for the bill, S. 1748, as a way to protect children from online harm by imposing “minimum safety standards on all social media and gaming platforms.”

In addition, the attorneys general are promoting KOSA as a way to future-proof these standards, as they say the bill’s duty of care provision would “establish a lasting standard that extends beyond the term of the settlement and adapts as technologies and design features evolve.”

The letter also reveals that the attorneys general view the bill as a way to cement the impact of a huge settlement reached with Meta earlier this year.

Keep reading

New Jersey Wants “Accountable” Chatbots, But At What Privacy Cost?

New Jersey is moving to treat AI chatbots as products under the state’s product liability law, and make their makers strictly liable for injuries their products cause – even if the company was careful and had no direct contract with the user.

A bill to this effect, A5607, was introduced on October 5, and after passing the Assembly Public Safety and Preparedness Committee on October 19, has been sent to the Appropriations Committee.

This means that users who are harmed by violations of the bill’s provisions could sue chatbot makers for actual damages or $5,000 per violation, while the attorney general would be able to seek civil penalties of $5,000 per violation.

The New Jersey bill would also restrict the use of chat logs and personal data for advertising, profiling, and training AI. This would represent a real gain for users, who are currently often subjected to this type of data harvesting and exploitation by tech companies.

The bill would also require providers to keep users’ chat logs and allow them to download these logs. What this means is that while on the one hand, users would have more control over their data, on the other, the provider would be forced to keep a record of all conversations that take place on their platform.

That is a store of highly personal and intimate records that can be accessed by law enforcement, other litigants, and hackers.

This is not merely theoretical, as we reported in October about a Florida woman who used the Claude chatbot as a “diary” – and got arrested after the system flagged one of her entries as suspicious. The local sheriff’s office then warned people that they are “never truly anonymous” when using AI.

The New Jersey bill’s provisions that are supposed to protect users’ privacy and safety could ultimately backfire, as the strict liability standard that would be imposed on companies could lead to even more surveillance of users.

As lawyer Scott S. Christie told Law.com, the bill would “open the floodgates” and explained that, “When there’s $5,000 in statutory damages per violation and you don’t have to prove any harm, in addition to the strict liability standard, you’re talking hundreds of thousands and perhaps millions of dollars per lawsuit.”

He also explained that the way the bill is written means that if a chatbot provider violates the statute with one user, “it’s probably violating as to all users.”

To avoid this, the obvious course of action for companies would be to watch their users more closely, verify their identities, and report them to the authorities when the algorithm decides that is warranted.

Keep reading

Taxpayers Federation heads to Supreme Court to fight limits on taxman’s power to demand your emails and texts

The Canadian Taxpayers Federation is intervening in a Supreme Court of Canada case that it says will decide how far government agencies, including the Canada Revenue Agency, can go in demanding Canadians’ private records.

“The government already takes enough of your money. It shouldn’t get a blank cheque to go snooping through your private emails, text messages and personal information too,” CTF general counsel Devin Drover told Rebel News.

The case is Ontario Securities Commission v. Binance Holdings Limited. In 2023, the OSC ordered the cryptocurrency exchange to turn over every communication about Ontario or Canada sent by any of its directors, officers, employees, contractors or consultants since January 1, 2021, with no limit on subject matter.

The Court of Appeal for Ontario struck down the demand in November 2025, calling it “staggering in its breadth.” The court ruled the order violated section 8 of the Charter, which protects against unreasonable search and seizure, because the regulator had no reasonable foundation to believe the documents were relevant to its investigation.

The OSC is now asking the Supreme Court to replace that test with a looser one, under which an agency could demand any records “rationally connected” to its inquiry. According to the CTF, the OSC’s own filings say the ruling will affect the CRA’s power to demand records under the Income Tax Act.

The CTF argues that in a tax audit, almost any record a person holds can be tied to their income, so a lower standard would hand auditors near-unlimited reach.

“Just because some government bureaucrat wants to dig through your private life doesn’t mean they should have the power to do it,” Drover said.

He pointed out that Binance, a multinational company, spent more than two years before three different bodies before any court ruled on its Charter argument.

“Most Canadians don’t have an army of lawyers or deep pockets to fight back when government agencies overstep their authority. That’s why we’re taking this fight to the Supreme Court,” Drover said. “The government needs to be reminded that Canadians have constitutional rights, and those rights don’t disappear just because the taxman comes knocking.”

The case lands as Ottawa moves to toughen the CRA’s hand. According to the CTF, the Carney government’s budget bill, C-31, now before a House of Commons committee, would let the CRA fine taxpayers $50 a day, to a maximum of $25,000, for failing to fully answer an information request.

“If the Supreme Court lowers the bar in this case, it lowers it for the taxman too,” Drover said in a statement. “A tax auditor could demand years of a small business owner’s emails and texts on a hunch, and Ottawa wants to fine people $50 a day until they comply.”

The Supreme Court has not yet set a hearing date.

Keep reading

Meta Ordered to Pay $25 Billion Penalty for Misleading Facebook Users About Data Privacy

A New Mexico judge on Wednesday ordered Meta to pay a $25 billion penalty for misleading Facebook users about data privacy.

The judgment is related to the Cambridge Analytica data privacy scandal from nearly 10 years ago.

The jury found that Meta had more than 40 million violations of New Mexico’s unfair practices act.

CNBC reported:

Meta was ordered to pay $25 billion in penalties by a New Mexico court on Wednesday as part of a data privacy case that stemmed from the company’s Cambridge Analytica scandal from nearly a decade ago.

The penalty, revealed in a court filing, comes after a jury in a Santa Fe courthouse found in September the social media giant liable for misleading state citizens about how it safeguards and collects user data and prevents harmful information from flourishing on its services.

Although the jury concluded that Meta had over 43 million violations of the state’s unfair practices act, with each transgression carrying a civil penalty as high as $5,000, a New Mexico judge was responsible for determining the ultimate fine. The Wednesday filing showed that the state was awarded $219.5 billion, but the penalty was ultimately reduced to $25 billion.

“The extraordinary number of willful violations found by the jury, the duration and repetition of the conduct, the breadth of subjects on which violations occurred, the involvement of senior Facebook leadership, the size of New Mexico audiences reached, and the clear intentional and systematic nature of Facebook’s repeated misstatements established in the trial record support the highest level of penalty allowed by the New Mexico Unfair Practices Act – $5,000 per violation found by the jury,” New Mexico district court judge Francis Mathew wrote in the filing.

The judge added that interest on the penalty shall accrue at the rate of 15% each year until the fine is paid off in full.

In August, a court ordered Meta to pay $567 million into a fund over child harm.

New Mexico Judge Bryan Biedscheid compared Meta to air pollution and called it a “public nuisance.”

“Although Meta is not alone in this regard, its social media platforms are a significant contributing factor to the current mental health crisis among New Mexico’s youth established by the substantial evidence in this case,” Judge Bryan Biedscheid wrote in the ruling over the summer, CNBC reported.

Keep reading

Your Browser Might Be Spying On You To Change The Price Of Items You Purchase

he more companies know about you, the more you can be exploited.

Your data profile is constantly being updated when you browse, shop online, or use your credit card. Websites and apps track your location, device, searches, purchases, shopping carts, mouse movements, and how long you look at a product.

Your data profile includes information from brokers, loyalty programs, credit records, advertising networks, and other platforms. AI groups you by estimating income, interests, and vulnerabilities.

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) began investigating in 2024, issuing demands for information to eight companies offering surveillance pricing products: Mastercard, Revionics, Bloomreach, JPMorgan Chase, Task Software, PROS, Accenture, and McKinsey & Company.

In January 2025, the FTC released preliminary findings showing a “hidden ecosystem of data brokers, digital platforms, and other intermediaries that specialize in monitoring and selling user data.”

The findings showed companies had access to extraordinarily detailed information. The FTC found a hidden ecosystem with at least 250 clients “that sell goods or services ranging from grocery stores to apparel retailers.”

Price manipulation is usually not obvious and can be quite sophisticated. Companies can withhold a discount, place expensive products at the top of your search results, or show a financially desperate customer a convenient yet costly financing option.

Investigations Show How Deep This Goes

The Princeton Review was caught charging between $6,600 and $8,400 for the same tutoring package based on customers’ ZIP codes. Asian residents were 1.8 times more likely to receive the higher price, including those in lower-income neighborhoods.

The company conveniently claimed it was based on business conditions. Maybe, but this demonstrates how personalized pricing can mimic discriminatory targeting.

Then we have Instacart “experimenting” with price differences on groceries. A Consumer Reports investigation involving more than 400 shoppers found identical grocery items were offered at different prices to different customers shopping at the same stores at the same time. Nearly three-quarters of the products tested showed price variations of as much as 23 percent.

The behavior isn’t just in the United States. The European Commission found deceptive practices by SHEIN, Apple, Temu, Vinted, Viagogo, Tinder, PayPal, Shopify, Amazon Prime, and more. Practices ranged from fake discounts (i.e., pretending to offer better deals by showing price reductions that are not based on the actual “prior prices”) to pressure selling (i.e., putting consumers under pressure to complete purchases using tactics like false purchase deadlines).

Paired with your personal data, these practices could be highly effective at getting you to pay more.

Keep reading

Meta Muse Exposes Users’ Personal, Business Secrets When They Share Conversations

Security researchers say Meta’s Muse AI assistant exposed thousands of users’ shared conversations because conversation titles were placed in subdomains that could be discovered through public DNS records. Meta has since suspended the sharing feature while it considers making changes. Ars Technica reports:Like many online services, Muse has allowed users to share searches, conversations, images, and similar content with other people. Such share features usually involve clicking an option to create a unique URL that anyone can use to load a page hosting the content. To keep potentially sensitive information from being accessible to unintended people, the URLs typically contain a long sequence of text that can’t be easily guessed.

Muse, which Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg said last month was “built from the ground up for privacy and security,” seems to take the same precautions. But a central design decision for constructing URLs has made the links easy to discover. As a result, researchers from security firm Claroc said they were able to enumerate 6,800 links Muse users created for sharing conversations with others. After opening a few hundred of them, the researchers found information that was clearly not intended to be publicly available… […]. “If you had asked us beforehand, we would have guessed that gathering these would take real effort,” the researchers wrote. “It took one query.”

[…] The easiest way to discover the URLs is to perform a passive DNS search through one of many available commercial services. Passive DNS records store the historical resolution of domain names to IP addresses, as well as nameserver, and mail-server records over time. Passive DNS systems typically collect DNS responses from sensors positioned at recursive DNS resolvers or other infrastructure. A passive DNS record is generally created when a monitoring system observes a DNS response. In the case here, once the intended party clicks on the share link, the DNS information is recorded in a searchable database.

Claroc researchers were able to discover the Muse share links because all of them use the domain name cf.metaaiusercontent.com. Discovery is further made easy by the decision to add the conversation name to the URL, along with a long string of text. Simplified examples of such links are home-sale-budget-9f21c8a3.cf.metaaiusercontent.com, q3-revenue-review-7b1e42f0.cf.metaaiusercontent.com, and loan-application-draft-a4c9e2.cf.metaaiusercontent.com. It’s this last design decision, putting the conversation title in the subdomain rather than in the URL path, that makes public discovery possible.

Keep reading