Analysis: Connecticut’s AR-15 Ban Defense Relies on Misreading Medieval English History

The Supreme Court is about to decide the fate of so-called assault weapons bans, but the state backing them misrepresents the key history that will determine the outcome.

Connecticut just filed its response brief in Grant v. Higgins, defending its ban on possessing unregistered AR-15s and similar firearms. It has been consolidated with Viramontes v. Cook County. Oral arguments will be heard December 2, 2026. In the brief, Connecticut justifies its ban by citing historical English laws from as far back as the 14th Century that it argues prohibited possession of several kinds of weapons. Given what it held in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen, the Supreme Court is unlikely to rely on English laws many decades or even centuries removed from the Founding when deciding the case.

However, even taken at face value, these older laws are not what Connecticut claims.

Connecticut first points to regulations on the lancegay. That weapon was “a type of spear or lance, but that it was probably considerably lighter than a full-length war lance,” according to the University of Bristol Centre for Medieval Studies’ David Scott-Macnab. Connecticut relies on two laws, one from 1383 and another from 1396, which it claims prohibited owning lancegays.

But the 1383 law only banned possessing a lancegay while riding. It prohibited carrying lancegays unless one had a special license from the King. Richard II later “affirmed the validity of his 1383 legislation” in 1396 with the second law Connecticut relies on and “ordained and assented that no man shall ride armed within the realm, against the form of the Statute of Northampton thereupon made, nor with launcegays.”

Again, this second law merely prohibited the carrying of lancegays while riding. English law did not ban possession of a lancegay in one’s home. Connecticut is misinterpreting these laws as a ban on possession to justify their ban on AR-15-style rifles.

Historical evidence demonstrates that lancegays weren’t just lawful to own; they were actually quite popular.

“Among the myriad items recorded in an inventory of the possessions of the English gentleman-soldier and landowner Sir John Fastolf Caister Castle, Norfolk, we find that his magna aula, or great hall, contained an assortment of weapons…a ‘Launce gay,’” Scott-Macnab wrote of the arms in 2009.

“[W]e find that Sir John Fastolfe was far from alone in owning such a weapon. Brother Hugh Middleton, commander of the English contingent of the Knights Hospitaler at Rhodes, owned one too,” he wrote.

Court records from the Borough of Nottingham show “[e]ven common folk with no military associations seem to have possessed the weapon, as we learn from a legal action brought by John Melburn of Nottingham, a weaver, for the return of a lancegay-shaft.”

If the lancegay was illegal to possess, Mr. Melburn could not have brought a judicial action to compel its return. Nor could his action have been successful, which it was. And “John Scrope” “bequeathed his ‘launchgay cum uno batillaxe’ to his brother in 1452” via a will which was legally registered. If the lancegay was illegal to possess, then Mr. Scrope would not have been able to legally bequeath his lancegay to his brother.

Further evidence that Englishmen were not prohibited from possessing lancegays comes from a “stern edict issued by Henry VI to the sheriff of Worcester in 1457” that “the king would not tolerate a variety of unlawful acts, including riding about armed with lancegays and other weapons.”

“The King to the Sheriff of Worcester, greeting. . . . We instruct you . . . to proclaim in public that no-one . . . ride on horseback armed with lances, lancegays, swords and other weapons, contrary to the laws and statutes promulgated and published on this issue . . . .’),” the edict said.

If there was a ban on possession of the lancegay, then this edict would not have included the lancegay in a ban on the carrying of weapons which were legal to own. In fact, Englishmen were long required to own many of the weapons in this list. The 1181 Assize of Arms required all British men to own arms commensurate with their financial ability to purchase them.

Connecticut has misinterpreted these laws as prohibitions on possession. In reality, it was legal to own lancegays in Medieval England.

Connecticut also relied on Medieval English restrictions on crossbows and handguns. The first of these is most readily distinguishable because it had an express exemption for home defense.  “None  shall  shoot  with  a Cross  Bow, unless  for  Defence  of  his  House,  other  than  a Lord,  or  a Person  having  zoo  Marks  Freehold  per  Ann,” it read.

These laws culminated in 1542’s Acte Concerning Crossbows and Handguns. It prohibited some Englishmen from possessing crossbows and handguns. But there are several differences between this law and Connecticut’s modern AR-15 ban.

First, this law only applied to the poor. It did not apply to those who “have lands, tenements, fees, annuities or office to the yearly value of one hundred pounds.” Thus, it was a class-based law that is irrelevant in deciding the scope of the American right to arms. Furthermore, the primary purpose behind England’s ban on crossbows and small handguns was to aid in the national defense. The express rationale of that law was to promote the use of the longbow.

“[S]erving men now of late have laid apart the good and laudable exercise of the long bow, which always heretofore hath been the surest safeguard and continual defense of this Realm of England, and an inestimable dread and terror to the enemies of the same,” it read.

Englishmen were encouraged, and often required, to own longbows in particular. Edward III of England’s declaration of 1363 expressly encouraged their use:

“Whereas the people of our realm, rich and poor alike, were accustomed formerly in their games to practise archery – whence by God’s help, it is well known that high honour and profit came to our realm, and no small advantage to ourselves in our warlike enterprises… that every man in the same country, if he be able-bodied, shall, upon holidays, make use, in his games, of bows and arrows… and so learn and practise archery,” he wrote.

Further, in 1511, Henry VIII ordered that all men under the age of 60 practice shooting regularly, and that fathers be responsible for providing their sons and young male servants with archery equipment and training. England even banned other sports to promote the practice of archery. The Unlawful Games Act of 1541 was an Act of the Parliament of England, designed to prohibit “Several new devised Games” that caused “the Decay of Archery.” All Men under the Age of sixty Years “shall have Bows and Arrows for shooting.” Men and children between seven “Years and Seventeen shall have a Bow and 2 Shafts.” Men above seventeen “shall keep a Bow and 4 Arrows.” That law remained in effect until the Gaming Act of 1845 repealed much of it.

The 16th Century saw the advent of crossbows and early firearms. As Justice Clarence Thomas wrote for the majority in Bruen, “Henry VIII worried that handguns threatened Englishmen’s proficiency with the longbow—a weapon many believed was crucial to English military victories in the 1300s and 1400s, including the legendary English victories at Crécy and Agincourt.” That concern over military readiness catalyzed the laws Connecticut cites, whereas Connecticut alleges its ban on AR-15 rifles prevents crime.

Thus, the “how” (a ban on possession just for the poor) and the “why” (national defense) of the 16th-century ban are different from Connecticut’s law. Connecticut’s claim that crossbows and handguns were completely banned because they were highly dangerous weapons is simply not true. To the extent they were restricted, it was because they were not effective enough in a military context.

Additionally, the complete arms bans that Connecticut did identify were very short-lived.

The first is Stuart Royal Proclamation No. 126 from 1613, which banned small handguns. However, this law was amended shortly after, in 1616, to ban only the making, selling, or carrying of them. And, contrary to Connecticut’s assertion that this law prohibited small handguns because they were exceptionally dangerous, the 1613 law makes clear those items were typically used by criminals. The 1616 law expanded on this and explained that these weapons were not suitable for military purposes or self-defense.

A ban on carry is not the same as the ban on unregistered “assault weapon” possession in Connecticut. Furthermore, the rationale for this prohibition was much different. The 1616 Stuart Royal Proclamation Number 160 said the weapons were prohibited because they were “vtterly vnseruiceable for defence, Militarie practise, or other lawfull vse, but odious, and noted Instruments of murther, and mischiefe.” As with the 1542 law discussed above, the concern was these weapons were not effective for self-defense or military purposes. Contrary to Connecticut’s representation, these weapons were not restricted because they were especially dangerous. Their carry was prohibited because their typical use lacked a lawful purpose.

At most, this law confirms what Heller already tells us: that the weapons protected by the right to arms are those in common use for lawful purposes.

Connecticut then relies on the Game Act of 1671 as an example of a law that banned all gun possession. There’s some dispute among historians about the scope of the law, but the text indicates it was merely designed to prevent the peasantry from hunting. It prohibited people who were not wealthy from having  “Guns, Bowes, Grey hounds, Setting-dogs, Ferretts, Cony-doggs, Lurchers, Hayes, Netts, Lowbells, Hare-pipes, Ginns, Snares or other Engines aforesaid” for hunting.

Historically, as the Duke Center for Firearms Law’s Catie Carberry has pointed out, the term gun did not refer to pistols. It makes sense that pistols were excluded because the law’s express purpose was to prevent the poor from hunting, and pistols are less suited for that purpose. While the law did cover guns when first passed, it was quickly replaced by the Game Act of 1692. That act superseded the previous act and removed “guns” from its list of prohibited items.

It is likely not a coincidence that this law was passed around the same time as the 1689 English Bill of Rights, which guaranteed “[t]hat the subjects which are Protestants may have arms for their defence suitable to their conditions and as allowed by law.” However, the 1692 Game Act and its subsequent amendments contained a clause which still prohibited any other “engine” which could be used for hunting–engine essentially meaning instrument.

Subsequent litigation demonstrated that these laws did not apply to firearms when not used for hunting. In 1739’s Rex v. Gardner, an individual was charged with violating the Game Act of 1705 for owning a gun. The court concluded that “a gun differs from nets and dogs, which can only be kept for an ill purpose, and therefore this conviction must be quashed.”

“[I]f the statute is to be construed so largely, as to extend to the bare having of any instrument, that may possibly be used in destroying game, it will be attended with very great inconvenience; there being scarce any, tho’ ever so useful, but what may be applied to that purpose,” the justices reasoned “And tho’ a gun may be used in destroying game, and when it is so, doth then fall within the words of the act; yet as it is an instrument proper, and frequently necessary to be kept and used for other purposes, as the killing of noxious vermin, and the like, it is not the having a gun, without applying it in the destruction of game, that is prohibited by the act.”

Similarly, in 1752’s Wingfield v. Stratford & Osman, a man challenged his conviction under the Game Act and the confiscation of his gun and dog. The prosecution’s plea was held faulty, but the court pointed out that it would have held for appellant in any case as the prosecution had not alleged that the gun had been used for killing game:

“It is not to be imagined, that it was the Intention of the Legislature, in making the 5 Ann.c.14 to disarm all the People of England,” the court wrote. “[A]s Guns are not expressly mentioned in that Statute, and as a Gun may be kept for the Defence of a Man’s House, and for divers other lawful Purposes, it was necessary to alledge, in order to its being comprehended within the Meaning of the Words ‘any other Engines to kill the Game’, that the Gun had been used for killing the Game.”

As these two cases make clear, the inclusion of guns in the Game Act was short-lived, and the Act was quickly amended to remove guns. Connecticut’s reliance on the Game Act of 1671 is misplaced.

The vast majority of the laws Connecticut relies on either did not ban the possession of arms or exempted the wealthy, and the ones that did ban possession did not last. Ultimately, the historical gun regulations the state relies on to defend its modern AR-15 ban did not operate in a similar manner.

Keep reading

Who checks the police when police collect the banned guns?

Regina Police Chief Lorilee Davies says her force is not “sweeping anything under the rug” after charging one of its own officers over a banned rifle.

Const. Sheldon Kowalchuk, a seven-year member of the Regina Police Service, is charged with breach of trust and unauthorized possession of a firearm. He allegedly kept a Bushmaster XM15-E2S, an AR-15-style rifle, that a member of the public surrendered during a 2022 provincial amnesty.

None of it has been proven in court. He is suspended with pay and due in Regina Provincial Court on December 15.

Justin Trudeau’s Liberal government made that rifle prohibited in May 2020. Owners have since been told to dispose of or deactivate guns like it, and the amnesty deadline for them was extended to 90 days after the Supreme Court rules on the ban.

During the 2022 amnesty, officers collected surrendered guns from homes. Police no longer do that job. Davies says that amnesty might have been one of the last.

She has declined to say how the rifle ended up with him.

Davies says the Saskatchewan Firearms Office, the province’s own body, brought the rifle to police attention in the spring of 2026. How the office learned of it has not been reported.

Regina police say the charges followed an investigation by their Professional Standards Unit and consultation with Crown prosecutors.

The surrender was in 2022 and the flag came in 2026, four years on.

Keep reading

HERE WE GO! Texas Democrats Launch MASSIVE Assault on Second Amendment Just DAYS After Historic Election Sweep — Nearly 20 Gun Control Bills Filed on FIRST DAY, Including Firearm Bans, Red Flag Orders, and Private Sale Restrictions!

Just days after Democrat Gina Hinojosa defeated three-term Republican Gov. Greg Abbott and Democrats seized control of the Texas House for the first time since 2002, the party wasted no time launching a full-scale assault on the Second Amendment.

On Monday, November 9, 2026, the very first day lawmakers could prefile bills for the 90th Legislature, Democrats introduced a package of roughly 20 (NRA-ILA counts roughly 35 total firearm-related bills, the vast majority anti-gun) sweeping new restrictions.

The 2027 session does not even convene until January 12, yet the gun-control agenda is already on full display.

Here are some of the other major firearm restrictions Democrats filed Monday:

SB 80 (Sen. Judith Zaffirini): A ban on so-called “assault weapons,” including possession. The bill targets commonly owned semiautomatic centerfire rifles that accept detachable magazines and feature features such as pistol grips. Bill text: capitol.texas.gov SB 80.

HB 218 (Rep. Ann Johnson of Houston): Repeals the 2025 Texas law (SB 1362, signed by Gov. Abbott) that banned red-flag orders and blocked localities from enforcing them. It creates extreme risk protective orders allowing family members, household members, or law enforcement to petition a court. A judge can issue a temporary ex parte order without notifying the gun owner or holding a hearing, forcing surrender of firearms to police within 24 hours. A full hearing comes later (within 14 days), after which the order can last a year and be renewed. Possession in violation is a Class A misdemeanor. Bill text: capitol.texas.gov HB 218.

HB 173 (Rep. Joe Moody of El Paso) and related bills (HB 606, HB 610, HB 771, HB 806, HB 857): Make it a state jail felony to transfer many semiautomatic rifles (those accepting detachable magazines and chambered larger than .22) to adults under 21. Exceptions exist for law enforcement, military, and some temporary loans, but the core restriction targets military-age adults.

HB 613: Imposes so-called universal background checks on private firearm transfers.

Keep reading

Supreme Court opens two-day hearing on Ottawa’s 2020 gun ban

The Supreme Court of Canada began hearing arguments in Ottawa on Monday in the challenge led by the Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights (CCFR) against the federal government’s May 2020 firearms ban. It is the first of two days that will test whether cabinet had the legal authority to outlaw the guns by regulation.

Nine justices, sitting in the court’s temporary home in the West Memorial Building, are hearing four appeals together. The 2020 order-in-council prohibited roughly 1,500 models and variants, including the AR-15 and Ruger Mini-14. Later additions have pushed the list past 2,500.

At the centre of the case is a limit Parliament wrote into the Criminal Code: cabinet may not prohibit a firearm it considers reasonable for hunting or sporting use in Canada. The appellants say cabinet ignored that limit.

Christine Generoux, an Ottawa gun owner representing herself, opened for the challengers. She warned that the government’s reasoning, that the guns could cause harm, could apply to any firearm and invites future bans. She accused Ottawa of “using our community as scapegoats to cover for their own poor public policy.”

CCFR counsel Michael Loberg of Calgary argued the banned rifles have long been used for hunting and sport shooting, and that cabinet overstepped the mandate Parliament gave it. The CCFR’s written argument says neither lower court asked whether the guns were actually used for those purposes.

The bench pushed back. Justices asked whether the owners had given enough weight to public safety in the balance cabinet tried to strike, and several pressed counsel on the details of the federal measures, according to reports from the courtroom.

Federal lawyers defended the ban as a reasonable use of cabinet’s broad discretion, justified by the risk that these guns make mass shootings deadlier. They say the prohibition affects only three to five per cent of gun owners and that thousands of other firearms remain legal for hunting and sport.

The challengers have lost twice already. The Federal Court dismissed the case in October 2023, and the Federal Court of Appeal unanimously upheld that ruling in April 2025. The Supreme Court granted leave in March.

The hearing resumes Tuesday with interveners. Alberta, Saskatchewan and Ontario are lined up against the ban, along with several firearms and shooting-sport groups. The Canadian Constitution Foundation will argue for a clearer test of when tools like the RCMP’s Firearms Reference Table amount to law. The Coalition for Gun Control is the only intervener explicitly backing Ottawa.

No ruling is expected this week. A decision is anticipated in 2027. Until then, the amnesty for owners of the banned guns continues, and it now runs until 90 days after the court rules.

Keep reading

Democrats File a Flood of Gun Restriction Bills Days After Republicans Lose the Texas House and Governor’s Office

After Republicans lost control of the Texas House and the governor’s office, Democrats have moved quickly to file a large set of bills that would restrict firearm transfers, possession, and use across the state. The proposals, introduced for the upcoming legislative session, range from temporary confiscation orders issued without a prior hearing to age limits on rifles, private-sale background checks, and expanded criminal penalties. With Democrats now holding the House majority and the governorship, these measures face a clearer path than they did under previous Republican majorities. The Senate remains under Republican control.

The bills filed so far include:

  • HB 218 (Johnson): would create extreme-risk protective orders, including temporary orders issued without notice. A family or household member or a peace officer could apply if they allege the person has a serious mental illness and poses an immediate danger because of access to firearms. The person would have to turn over their guns within 24 hours; a full order would last up to a year and could be renewed. Possessing a gun in violation would be a Class A misdemeanor.
  • HB 173 (Moody): would make it a state jail felony to transfer a semiautomatic rifle that takes a detachable magazine and is larger than .22 caliber to anyone under 21, with exceptions for peace officers, current or honorably discharged military, and some temporary loans at a range or hunt.
  • HB 576 (Lalani): would bar registered sex offenders from buying a firearm, but only for registration based on an offense committed on or after Sept. 1, 2027.
  • HB 103 (Martinez): would expand the state crime of reckless discharge of a firearm so it also covers counties of 500,000 or more people, not just cities of 100,000 or more.
  • SB 80 (Zaffirini): would prohibit certain transfers, purchases, and possession of assault weapons and would create criminal offenses.
  • HB 606 (Lalani): would prohibit transferring firearms to, or the purchase or possession of firearms by, people under 21, and would create a criminal offense.
  • HB 610 (Lalani): would prohibit transferring firearms to certain recipients under 21.
  • HB 857 (Anchía): would prohibit transferring certain semiautomatic rifles to certain recipients under 21, and would create a criminal offense and increase a penalty.
  • HB 771 (Sethi): would prohibit transferring certain semiautomatic rifles to certain recipients, and would create a criminal offense and increase a penalty.
  • HB 806 (Reynolds): would prohibit transferring semiautomatic rifles to certain recipients and would increase a criminal penalty.
  • HB 613 (Lalani): would require a national instant criminal background check on private firearm transfers and would create a criminal offense.
  • HB 612 (Lalani): would prohibit a sex offender from possessing a firearm.
  • HB 609 (Lalani): would increase the criminal penalty for making a firearm accessible to a child.
  • HB 658 (Moody): would change the prosecution and punishment of making a firearm accessible to a child and would increase a criminal penalty.
  • HB 618 (Moody): would restrict transferring firearm magazines to people who are prohibited from possessing the type of firearm the magazine is made for, and would create a criminal offense.
  • HB 659 (Moody): would require licensed firearms dealers to report certain sales or transfers of multiple firearms or magazines to law enforcement, and would create a criminal offense.
  • HB 660 (Moody): would require certain people already prohibited from owning or possessing a firearm to dispose of firearms they own, possess, or control.
  • HB 712 (Gámez): would address a city or county’s authority to regulate or prohibit carrying a firearm in certain libraries.
  • HB 776 (Sethi): would address expulsion-related offenses involving possessing, carrying, exhibiting, or using a firearm on or within 1,000 feet of school property.
  • HB 859 (Anchía): would increase the criminal penalty for discharging a firearm in certain municipalities.

The volume of filings marks a clear shift following the recent election results that ended years of Republican majorities in the House and the executive branch. Whether any of the proposals advance will depend on the Republican-controlled Senate and the priorities of the new governor once the session begins.

Keep reading

Governor-Elect Amy Klobuchar Promises Passage of ‘Assault Weapons’ Ban

In a Wednesday press conference, Minnesota Governor-Elect Amy Klobuchar (D) promised passage of the “assault weapons” ban that eluded Gov. Tim Walz (D) during late 2025 and throughout 2026.

The ban was pushed in response to the August 27, 2025, Annunciation Catholic School shooting, where a transgender shooting suspect killed two children, wounded 14 others, and left behind a video saying, “F*ck those kids.”

The transgender shooting suspect had three guns — a rifle, a shotgun, and a pistol — and opened fire on schoolchildren as they sat in Mass.

Democrats and other leftist politicians in Minnesota responded by pushing a ban on “assault weapons,” “high capacity” magazines, and “ghost guns.” It failed to pass the legislature despite Gov. Walz pushing with all his might.

On Wednesday, Governor-Elect Klobuchar made clear the passage of the bill is a priority for her.

Bring Me The News quoted her saying, “The gun safety bill is going to get passed. And I am so excited to be working with the leaders on this.”

Keep reading

Ohio Woman ‘Did What She Had to Do to Save Her Life’ but Still Faces Charges

On Halloween night, a woman named Deryka Minor suffered a vicious assault at a Cincinnati nightclub. According to Minor’s attorney Clyde Bennett, 20-year-old Kameiro Blair-Martin, who worked at the nightclub as a barback and busser, assaulted his client.

Bennett says Blair-Martin punched Minor in the face at least 15 or 16 times, leaving her close to losing consciousness. As the beating continued, he allegedly reached toward his waistband in a manner that Minor interpreted as an attempt to draw a firearm.

That’s when Minor drew her own handgun and fired one shot, striking and killing Blair-Martin.

According to Bennett, Blair-Martin was armed and that a gun was subsequently recovered beside him. Bennett says Minor had never met Blair-Martin and still does not know why he attacked her.

During a court hearing last Wednesday, a Cincinnati police detective agreed that Minor was the victim of an assault and acted to defend herself. Blair-Martin’s homicide has been deemed a justifiable use of deadly force, but Minor still faces charges for unlawfully carrying a concealed firearm because she’s not old enough to lawfully carry one.

Just like her assailant, Deryka Minor is 20 years old. And under Ohio law, you must be 21 to carry, with or without a valid carry license. Unlawful concealed carry of a loaded firearm, or one with ammunition readily available, is a fourth-degree felony in the Buckeye State. It’s also a third-degree felony to unlawfully carry a concealed handgun in an establishment where liquor is served on the premises. Assuming the business hadn’t posted signage declaring it a “gun-free zone,” a 21-year-old could have lawfully brought a gun into Memories Lounge, but it was against the law for Minor to do so.

Keep reading

OH GOODY: Rep. Jamie Raskin Already Talking About Creating a National GUN REGISTRY

Maryland Democrat Jamie Raskin is apparently going to be the chair of the House Judiciary Committee when Dems take power in January and he is already talking about creating a national gun registry.

There’s only one reason why he and other Democrats would want to do that, and it has nothing to do with protecting your Constitutional rights.

These people are not even in power yet and they are already salivating about all of their pet issues.

From the Baltimore Banner:

As chair, Raskin said his priorities would include legislation requiring background checks on private gun sales, not just purchases from licensed dealers. Republicans have argued that such bills are unnecessarily restrictive on hobbyists and people selling firearms to their friends or from their personal collections.

Raskin also said legislation is needed to increase scrutiny of antitrust settlements, which he accuses the Trump administration of using in a “pay-to-play” system that rewards politically connected corporations.

In the wake of their victories, it’s in Democrats’ best interest to “focus very heavily on getting some visible things done,” said Roger Hartley, a professor at the University of Baltimore College of Public Affairs. “And then very smartly pick the right battles to hold the administration accountable — to show off what damage they did and then repair it.”

Democrats told voters they were all about lowering prices. They lied.

Keep reading

Trump DOJ Admits Handgun Ban Is Unconstitutional, Still Fights Gun Owners in Court

The Trump administration has admitted that the federal government cannot constitutionally prohibit licensed firearm dealers from selling handguns to law-abiding adults ages 18 to 20. Yet the Department of Justice is still fighting in federal court to prevent gun-rights organizations from securing lasting judicial protection against the very same unconstitutional law.

On November 4, Firearms Policy Coalition (FPC) filed a reply brief with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit in FPC v. ATF, formerly Reese v. ATF. The filing challenges DOJ’s attempt to avoid further judicial relief nearly six years after FPC, the Second Amendment Foundation (SAF), and the Louisiana Shooting Association first challenged the federal handgun purchase restrictions.

The plaintiffs have already won the constitutional argument. Now they are fighting to ensure that victory actually protects the people whose rights were violated.

DOJ Admits the Federal Handgun Ban Violates the Second Amendment

In January 2025, the Fifth Circuit ruled that federal restrictions prohibiting federally licensed dealers from selling handguns and handgun ammunition to adults ages 18 to 20 violated the Second Amendment. The decision represented a significant victory for young Americans who enjoy the same constitutional rights as other adults but have been denied access to the ordinary commercial handgun market.

On September 17, 2026, the Trump administration’s Office of Legal Counsel issued an opinion agreeing that the restrictions were unconstitutional. The DOJ acknowledged that these adults are among “the people” protected by the Second Amendment and that the government could not justify the prohibition under the Supreme Court’s historical-tradition standard.

But rather than agree to the broader judicial relief sought by the organizations that successfully challenged the law, the Justice Department now argues that its change in legal position makes the remaining lawsuit moot. Essentially, DOJ maintains that because the administration no longer considers the restrictions enforceable, a broader court order is unnecessary.

Keep reading

Virginia’s Democrat AG Jay Jones: AR-15s Are Semiautomatic Machine Guns

In a brief filed to the Supreme Court of the United States in support of “assault weapons” bans, Virginia Attorney General Jay Jones claimed AR-15s are machine guns even though they do not shoot in full automatic like machine guns do.

The Federalist noted that Jones filed his brief to SCOTUS on Wednesday, wherein he wrote, “AR-15s bear nearly all the same features that take machine guns outside the Second Amendment’s protection.”

He also claimed, “AR-15s are machineguns, except that they — at least to start — have semiautomatic fire rather than automatic fire.”

Gun Owners of California commented in an X post on Jones’ filing, writing, “’AR-15s are machineguns, except that they…have semiautomatic fire rather than automatic fire.’ Read that again. Someone actually wrote this, presumably proofread it, and decided it belonged in a legal brief to the Supreme Court. Incredible.”

Jones’ suggestion that AR-15s are semiautomatic machine guns flies in the face of SCOTUS’s June 14, 2024, ruling which struck down the bump stock ban. In that ruling, Clarence Thomas opened the majority opinion by observing: “Congress has long restricted access to ‘machineguns,’ a category of firearms defined by the ability to ‘shoot, automatically more than one shot . . . by a single function of the trigger.’ Semiautomatic firearms, which require shooters to reengage the trigger for every shot, are not machineguns.”

Keep reading