Rifle Murders Declined After Federal ‘Assault Weapons’ Ban Expired, New FBI Data Analysis Finds

As the U.S. Supreme Court prepares to decide whether states can ban AR-15s and other commonly owned semiautomatic rifles, a new analysis of FBI crime data is challenging one of the gun-control lobby’s central arguments. Despite decades of warnings about the supposed dangers of these firearms, rifles account for a smaller share of firearm murders today than they did when the federal government’s so-called “assault weapons” ban was in effect.

According to a November 4 analysis published by the Crime Prevention Research Center (CPRC), rifles accounted for an average of 4.9% of firearm murders during the federal ban from 1995 through 2004. After the ban expired, that figure fell to just 3.6%, even as the estimated number of AR-15s and AK-47s in civilian circulation increased dramatically.

The findings arrive ahead of December 2, 2026, when the Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins, two consolidated cases challenging bans on commonly owned semiautomatic rifles. The cases could determine whether politicians can continue prohibiting America’s most popular rifle platform despite its widespread lawful ownership and the constitutional protections recognized in District of Columbia v. Heller.

Keep reading

Analysis: Connecticut’s AR-15 Ban Defense Relies on Misreading Medieval English History

The Supreme Court is about to decide the fate of so-called assault weapons bans, but the state backing them misrepresents the key history that will determine the outcome.

Connecticut just filed its response brief in Grant v. Higgins, defending its ban on possessing unregistered AR-15s and similar firearms. It has been consolidated with Viramontes v. Cook County. Oral arguments will be heard December 2, 2026. In the brief, Connecticut justifies its ban by citing historical English laws from as far back as the 14th Century that it argues prohibited possession of several kinds of weapons. Given what it held in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen, the Supreme Court is unlikely to rely on English laws many decades or even centuries removed from the Founding when deciding the case.

However, even taken at face value, these older laws are not what Connecticut claims.

Connecticut first points to regulations on the lancegay. That weapon was “a type of spear or lance, but that it was probably considerably lighter than a full-length war lance,” according to the University of Bristol Centre for Medieval Studies’ David Scott-Macnab. Connecticut relies on two laws, one from 1383 and another from 1396, which it claims prohibited owning lancegays.

But the 1383 law only banned possessing a lancegay while riding. It prohibited carrying lancegays unless one had a special license from the King. Richard II later “affirmed the validity of his 1383 legislation” in 1396 with the second law Connecticut relies on and “ordained and assented that no man shall ride armed within the realm, against the form of the Statute of Northampton thereupon made, nor with launcegays.”

Again, this second law merely prohibited the carrying of lancegays while riding. English law did not ban possession of a lancegay in one’s home. Connecticut is misinterpreting these laws as a ban on possession to justify their ban on AR-15-style rifles.

Historical evidence demonstrates that lancegays weren’t just lawful to own; they were actually quite popular.

“Among the myriad items recorded in an inventory of the possessions of the English gentleman-soldier and landowner Sir John Fastolf Caister Castle, Norfolk, we find that his magna aula, or great hall, contained an assortment of weapons…a ‘Launce gay,’” Scott-Macnab wrote of the arms in 2009.

“[W]e find that Sir John Fastolfe was far from alone in owning such a weapon. Brother Hugh Middleton, commander of the English contingent of the Knights Hospitaler at Rhodes, owned one too,” he wrote.

Court records from the Borough of Nottingham show “[e]ven common folk with no military associations seem to have possessed the weapon, as we learn from a legal action brought by John Melburn of Nottingham, a weaver, for the return of a lancegay-shaft.”

If the lancegay was illegal to possess, Mr. Melburn could not have brought a judicial action to compel its return. Nor could his action have been successful, which it was. And “John Scrope” “bequeathed his ‘launchgay cum uno batillaxe’ to his brother in 1452” via a will which was legally registered. If the lancegay was illegal to possess, then Mr. Scrope would not have been able to legally bequeath his lancegay to his brother.

Further evidence that Englishmen were not prohibited from possessing lancegays comes from a “stern edict issued by Henry VI to the sheriff of Worcester in 1457” that “the king would not tolerate a variety of unlawful acts, including riding about armed with lancegays and other weapons.”

“The King to the Sheriff of Worcester, greeting. . . . We instruct you . . . to proclaim in public that no-one . . . ride on horseback armed with lances, lancegays, swords and other weapons, contrary to the laws and statutes promulgated and published on this issue . . . .’),” the edict said.

If there was a ban on possession of the lancegay, then this edict would not have included the lancegay in a ban on the carrying of weapons which were legal to own. In fact, Englishmen were long required to own many of the weapons in this list. The 1181 Assize of Arms required all British men to own arms commensurate with their financial ability to purchase them.

Connecticut has misinterpreted these laws as prohibitions on possession. In reality, it was legal to own lancegays in Medieval England.

Connecticut also relied on Medieval English restrictions on crossbows and handguns. The first of these is most readily distinguishable because it had an express exemption for home defense.  “None  shall  shoot  with  a Cross  Bow, unless  for  Defence  of  his  House,  other  than  a Lord,  or  a Person  having  zoo  Marks  Freehold  per  Ann,” it read.

These laws culminated in 1542’s Acte Concerning Crossbows and Handguns. It prohibited some Englishmen from possessing crossbows and handguns. But there are several differences between this law and Connecticut’s modern AR-15 ban.

First, this law only applied to the poor. It did not apply to those who “have lands, tenements, fees, annuities or office to the yearly value of one hundred pounds.” Thus, it was a class-based law that is irrelevant in deciding the scope of the American right to arms. Furthermore, the primary purpose behind England’s ban on crossbows and small handguns was to aid in the national defense. The express rationale of that law was to promote the use of the longbow.

“[S]erving men now of late have laid apart the good and laudable exercise of the long bow, which always heretofore hath been the surest safeguard and continual defense of this Realm of England, and an inestimable dread and terror to the enemies of the same,” it read.

Englishmen were encouraged, and often required, to own longbows in particular. Edward III of England’s declaration of 1363 expressly encouraged their use:

“Whereas the people of our realm, rich and poor alike, were accustomed formerly in their games to practise archery – whence by God’s help, it is well known that high honour and profit came to our realm, and no small advantage to ourselves in our warlike enterprises… that every man in the same country, if he be able-bodied, shall, upon holidays, make use, in his games, of bows and arrows… and so learn and practise archery,” he wrote.

Further, in 1511, Henry VIII ordered that all men under the age of 60 practice shooting regularly, and that fathers be responsible for providing their sons and young male servants with archery equipment and training. England even banned other sports to promote the practice of archery. The Unlawful Games Act of 1541 was an Act of the Parliament of England, designed to prohibit “Several new devised Games” that caused “the Decay of Archery.” All Men under the Age of sixty Years “shall have Bows and Arrows for shooting.” Men and children between seven “Years and Seventeen shall have a Bow and 2 Shafts.” Men above seventeen “shall keep a Bow and 4 Arrows.” That law remained in effect until the Gaming Act of 1845 repealed much of it.

The 16th Century saw the advent of crossbows and early firearms. As Justice Clarence Thomas wrote for the majority in Bruen, “Henry VIII worried that handguns threatened Englishmen’s proficiency with the longbow—a weapon many believed was crucial to English military victories in the 1300s and 1400s, including the legendary English victories at Crécy and Agincourt.” That concern over military readiness catalyzed the laws Connecticut cites, whereas Connecticut alleges its ban on AR-15 rifles prevents crime.

Thus, the “how” (a ban on possession just for the poor) and the “why” (national defense) of the 16th-century ban are different from Connecticut’s law. Connecticut’s claim that crossbows and handguns were completely banned because they were highly dangerous weapons is simply not true. To the extent they were restricted, it was because they were not effective enough in a military context.

Additionally, the complete arms bans that Connecticut did identify were very short-lived.

The first is Stuart Royal Proclamation No. 126 from 1613, which banned small handguns. However, this law was amended shortly after, in 1616, to ban only the making, selling, or carrying of them. And, contrary to Connecticut’s assertion that this law prohibited small handguns because they were exceptionally dangerous, the 1613 law makes clear those items were typically used by criminals. The 1616 law expanded on this and explained that these weapons were not suitable for military purposes or self-defense.

A ban on carry is not the same as the ban on unregistered “assault weapon” possession in Connecticut. Furthermore, the rationale for this prohibition was much different. The 1616 Stuart Royal Proclamation Number 160 said the weapons were prohibited because they were “vtterly vnseruiceable for defence, Militarie practise, or other lawfull vse, but odious, and noted Instruments of murther, and mischiefe.” As with the 1542 law discussed above, the concern was these weapons were not effective for self-defense or military purposes. Contrary to Connecticut’s representation, these weapons were not restricted because they were especially dangerous. Their carry was prohibited because their typical use lacked a lawful purpose.

At most, this law confirms what Heller already tells us: that the weapons protected by the right to arms are those in common use for lawful purposes.

Connecticut then relies on the Game Act of 1671 as an example of a law that banned all gun possession. There’s some dispute among historians about the scope of the law, but the text indicates it was merely designed to prevent the peasantry from hunting. It prohibited people who were not wealthy from having  “Guns, Bowes, Grey hounds, Setting-dogs, Ferretts, Cony-doggs, Lurchers, Hayes, Netts, Lowbells, Hare-pipes, Ginns, Snares or other Engines aforesaid” for hunting.

Historically, as the Duke Center for Firearms Law’s Catie Carberry has pointed out, the term gun did not refer to pistols. It makes sense that pistols were excluded because the law’s express purpose was to prevent the poor from hunting, and pistols are less suited for that purpose. While the law did cover guns when first passed, it was quickly replaced by the Game Act of 1692. That act superseded the previous act and removed “guns” from its list of prohibited items.

It is likely not a coincidence that this law was passed around the same time as the 1689 English Bill of Rights, which guaranteed “[t]hat the subjects which are Protestants may have arms for their defence suitable to their conditions and as allowed by law.” However, the 1692 Game Act and its subsequent amendments contained a clause which still prohibited any other “engine” which could be used for hunting–engine essentially meaning instrument.

Subsequent litigation demonstrated that these laws did not apply to firearms when not used for hunting. In 1739’s Rex v. Gardner, an individual was charged with violating the Game Act of 1705 for owning a gun. The court concluded that “a gun differs from nets and dogs, which can only be kept for an ill purpose, and therefore this conviction must be quashed.”

“[I]f the statute is to be construed so largely, as to extend to the bare having of any instrument, that may possibly be used in destroying game, it will be attended with very great inconvenience; there being scarce any, tho’ ever so useful, but what may be applied to that purpose,” the justices reasoned “And tho’ a gun may be used in destroying game, and when it is so, doth then fall within the words of the act; yet as it is an instrument proper, and frequently necessary to be kept and used for other purposes, as the killing of noxious vermin, and the like, it is not the having a gun, without applying it in the destruction of game, that is prohibited by the act.”

Similarly, in 1752’s Wingfield v. Stratford & Osman, a man challenged his conviction under the Game Act and the confiscation of his gun and dog. The prosecution’s plea was held faulty, but the court pointed out that it would have held for appellant in any case as the prosecution had not alleged that the gun had been used for killing game:

“It is not to be imagined, that it was the Intention of the Legislature, in making the 5 Ann.c.14 to disarm all the People of England,” the court wrote. “[A]s Guns are not expressly mentioned in that Statute, and as a Gun may be kept for the Defence of a Man’s House, and for divers other lawful Purposes, it was necessary to alledge, in order to its being comprehended within the Meaning of the Words ‘any other Engines to kill the Game’, that the Gun had been used for killing the Game.”

As these two cases make clear, the inclusion of guns in the Game Act was short-lived, and the Act was quickly amended to remove guns. Connecticut’s reliance on the Game Act of 1671 is misplaced.

The vast majority of the laws Connecticut relies on either did not ban the possession of arms or exempted the wealthy, and the ones that did ban possession did not last. Ultimately, the historical gun regulations the state relies on to defend its modern AR-15 ban did not operate in a similar manner.

Keep reading

Liberals admit ‘assault-style firearm’ has no legal definition as RCMP says it doesn’t track crimes involving them

The federal government has acknowledged there is no legal definition of an “assault-style firearm,” while the RCMP says it does not specifically track crimes committed with the very category of firearms Ottawa has spent years prohibiting and buying back.

The admissions came in a September 21 response to order paper question Q-1375, submitted by Conservative MP Alex Ruff of Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound.

Asked directly for the government’s definition of an assault-style firearm, Public Safety Canada responded: “There is no legal definition of an assault-style firearm.”

Instead, the department said firearms are legally classified according to criteria contained in Section 84(1) of the Criminal Code. It said firearms prohibited through the May 2020, December 2024 and March 2025 measures share technical characteristics that led the government to deem them unsuitable for civilian use.

The response becomes more striking when Ruff asks for data showing how frequently these so-called assault-style firearms actually appear in crime.

The RCMP said it “does not collect data specifically regarding gun crimes for assault-style firearms.”

Nor could the force say how many firearms it traced between 2021 and 2025 fell into the government’s assault-style category. The RCMP said that information is not tracked in its existing database and would require a manual review.

That leaves Ottawa unable to provide a basic crime statistic for a category at the centre of its Assault-Style Firearms Compensation Program.

The tracing data the RCMP does collect shows a sharp increase in firearms suspected of having been illegally imported.

In 2025, the Canadian National Firearms Tracing Centre conducted 1,464 crime-related traces involving firearms reasonably suspected of being illegally imported, up from 487 in 2024, 271 in 2023, 572 in 2022 and just 66 in 2021.

By comparison, 326 crime-related traces in 2025 involved firearms identified as manufactured in Canada.

The RCMP completed 3,011 traces in 2025 involving firearms used or suspected of being used in crimes. That means suspected illegal imports accounted for a substantial share of the crime-related traces reported that year.

The government’s own data also has significant gaps. The RCMP only began collecting information about stolen firearms in 2023 and does not collect information about lost firearms through the tracing centre.

And while Ottawa has prohibited hundreds of firearm makes and models under measures explicitly described as targeting “assault-style firearms,” the RCMP told Parliament it cannot provide the number of traces involving those firearms by reference number, make or model because it does not specifically collect an assault-style designation.

Ottawa’s compensation program is nevertheless explicitly called the Assault-Style Firearms Compensation Program, relying on a definition that doesn’t exist.

Keep reading

Democrats Demand “Assault Weapons” Ban After Trans Mass Shooting In Minneapolis

In the US, gun deaths are often the focus of progressive and international criticism, with claims that the nation is a wellspring of violence and murder that could be solved simply by banning firearms.  The disdain of the political left for the 2nd Amendment is no secret and their efforts to erase gun rights from the Constitution is a constant point of contention within American society.  

Of course, this means that Democrats are required to ignore every other contributing factor to any shooting and deflect when they are confronted with inconvenient truths.  Leftists are, once again, attempting to redirect public discourse as yet another trans shooter has hit the news feeds.  The Minneapolis killer is one of at least five active shooters since 2018 that were confirmed as transgender. 

Multiple other active shooter events have taken place in which the trans status of the killers was suspected but never revealed by authorities (authorities tried to hide Audrey Hale’s trans status and her manifesto, for example).

In the case of the Robert Westman, a male posing as a female, notes from a manifesto and other evidence indicates that the trans ideology was central to his decision to murder two children and injure 17 others at a Christian school.  It was the direct inspiration for the attack.

However, Democrat leaders and media figures like former Biden Press Secretary Jen Psaki argue otherwise.  They claim that the availability of “assault rifles” is the real cause, not the insane political philosophy that ruled over Westman’s every waking moment.  Psaki shed alligator tears for the children of the Church of the Annunciation, while simultaneously denying that the trans ideology had anything to do with it and blaming conservatives for not supporting a firearms ban.

Keep reading

Why ‘You Don’t Need That for Hunting’ Should Never Fly

Right now, there’s a lot of discussion about so-called assault weapons. The shooting earlier this week in a Manhattan office building by a gunman wielding one was always going to spark such a debate.

Undoubtedly, you’ve heard someone, either now or in the past, use the phrase, “You don’t need that to hunt deer.” They might be referring to the type of weapon, the magazine capacity, or anything of the sort.

For Fudds, that’s ample reason to support some gun control measure or another. After all, their old, trusty bolt-action or lever gun isn’t up for banning. They’ll keep all of their guns, so it doesn’t matter.

Doing so, however, is a terrible mistake.

First, there’s the age-old argument that the Second Amendment isn’t about hunting. It’s not. I’ve talked about how it’s not countless times, and I’m just one of a legion of voices saying so.

Yet there’s another reason why this argument should be rejected outright beyond the text of the Second Amendment.

See, if we use the idea that what we need for hunting deer or other game animals is the criteria to be considered for what should be legal or not, then absolutely no firearm will survive.

Those trusty bolt-actions and lever-action guns? You don’t actually need those to hunt deer, elk, bear, or anything else. Archery exists, and really, how many mass killings do we see with those? I mean, I can only think of one, and that wasn’t even here, so sure, archery is a much safer option for hunting, and then those sniper rifles and cowboy guns can be taken off the streets where they won’t harm anyone.

After all, didn’t you guys already agree that if you don’t need it for hunting, it’s OK to ban it?

The problem with “don’t need it for hunting” is that someone will decide to ramp that up to the next degree. And, since archery equipment can be considered “arms,” they could even use that to argue that they’re not violating the Second Amendment at all with a total gun ban since you still have access to arms that can be used for hunting.

Hell, back in the day, spears were hunting weapons. Would we like to see a world where archery equipment was too cutting-edge and capable of being used for a massacre?

We can make the Second Amendment argument until we’re blue in the face. It’s absolutely true, but it doesn’t convince a lot of people predisposed to accept limits on constitutionally protected rights. What we have to do is address the problems with arguments as they’re presented, including the slippery slope on something like this.

Keep reading

Rhode Island Democrats Ban Sale, Manufacture of ‘Assault Weapons’

Rhode Island’s Democrat-run legislature passed a bill Friday banning the instate sale and manufacture of “assault weapons.”

The measure now heads to Gov. Dan McKee’s (D) desk.

The Associated Press reported that state Rep. Rebecca Kislak (D) contended for the ban, suggesting it is “an incremental move that brings Rhode Island in line with neighboring states.”

The ban “only applies to the sale and manufacturing of assault weapons and not possession.”

Gov. McKee reacted to Friday’s passage of the ban with an X post, saying: I’m proud that Rhode Island took an important step forward in protecting our communities from gun violence. I included an assault weapons ban in my budget for this very reason — and as a result, tonight we saw progress.

Keep reading

Trump DOJ Files Amicus Brief Supporting Challenge to Illinois ‘Assault Weapons’ Ban

On June 13, 2025, the Civil Rights Division of President Donald Trump’s Department of Justice announced the filing of an amicus brief supporting an NRA lawsuit against Illinois’ “assault weapons” ban.

The brief was announced by Assistant Attorney General for DOJ’s Civil Rights Division Harmeet Dhillon. In a post to X, Dhillon noted, “The Second Amendment is not a second-class right. See you in court, Illinois.”

The amicus brief’s introduction points to Bruen (2022) and says in part:

Three years ago, the Supreme Court issued a landmark decision meant to break a habit developed by some States of treating the Second Amendment as “a second-class right, subject to an entirely different body of rules than the other” constitutional rights. …[Bruen] (2022).

Regrettably, not every State got the message. Just a few months after Bruen, Illinois outlawed some of the most commonly used rifles and magazines in America via a so-called “assault weapons” ban. In doing so,  Illinois violated the Supreme Court’s clear directive that States cannot prohibit arms that are “in common use” by law-abiding citizens for lawful purposes. …[Heller] (2008).

Keep reading

U.S. Sen. Mark Kelly Introduces New “Assault Weapons” Ban

Dubbed the “GOSAFE Act,” this unconstitutional bill would regulate the sale, transfer and manufacture of “gas-operated semi-automatic firearms by establishing a list and prevent modifications of so-called “prohibited firearms.”

Similar legislation has been introduced in state legislatures and has even been signed into law by Colorado Governor Jared Polis in recent weeks.

According to a press release from the bill sponsor U.S. Senator Mark Kelly (D-AZ) the GOSAFE Act would:

Regulate the sale, transfer, and manufacture of gas-operated semi-automatic firearms by:

  • Establishing a list of prohibited firearms;
  • Preventing modifications of permissible firearms;
  • Mandating that future gas-operated designs are approved before manufacture;
  • Preventing firearm self-assembly and manufacturing;
  • Prohibiting machinegun conversion devices;
  • Limit high-capacity ammunition devices;

This legislation is certainly more restrictive than what even California and New York have on the books regarding semi-automatic firearms.

Keep reading

Federal Judge Enjoins Enforcement of the Illinois ‘Assault Weapon’ Ban

A federal judge in Illinois recently issued a permanent injunction against that state’s “assault weapon” ban, deeming it inconsistent with the Second Amendment. The Protect Illinois Communities Act (PICA) “is an unconstitutional affront to the Second Amendment and must be enjoined,” U.S. District Judge Stephen P. McGlynn wrote in Barnett v. Raoul, which combines several challenges to the law, on Friday. “The Government may not deprive law-abiding citizens of their guaranteed right to self-defense as a means of offense.”

McGlynn imposed a 30-day stay on his injunction to allow an appeal that seems likely to succeed. Last year in Bevis v. City of Naperville, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit vacated a preliminary injunction against PICA that McGlynn issued in April 2023. The 7th Circuit concluded that the state was likely to prevail in its defense of the law.

The 168-page opinion that McGlynn issued on Friday, which followed a bench trial, aims to reconcile the 7th Circuit’s reasoning, which was based on a distinction between “military” weapons and “Arms protected by the Second Amendment,” with the U.S. Supreme Court’s Second Amendment precedents. That’s a tall order. But the Firearms Policy Coalition (FPC), which represents the plaintiffs in one of the PICA lawsuits, argues that the evidence presented at trial showed that “PICA fails even under the Seventh Circuit’s misguided test,” which it says “conflicts with binding Supreme Court precedent.”

Illinois legislators enacted PICA in January 2023, six months after a gunman used a Smith & Wesson M&P15 rifle to kill seven people at an Independence Day parade in Highland Park. Among other things, the law bans a long list of specific rifle models, along with any semi-automatic rifle that accepts detachable magazines and has one or more of six listed features: a pistol grip or thumbhole stock, a protruding grip, a folding or adjustable stock, a flash suppressor, a grenade launcher, or a barrel shroud. PICA also bans “large capacity ammunition feeding devices,” defined to include rifle magazines that hold more than 10 rounds and pistol magazines that hold more than 15 rounds.

Illinois House Speaker Chris Welch (D–Westchester) said the law was aimed at “weapons of war.” That phrase suggested that Welch was talking about selective-fire rifles like those carried by U.S. soldiers, which can shoot automatically.

That was clearly not true. Such rifles are strictly regulated under federal law, which has forbidden sales of newly manufactured machine guns to civilians since 1986. PICA does not deal with machine guns; it deals with semi-automatic firearms, which fire one round per trigger pull.

Keep reading

Biden Guarantees Assault Weapons Ban Passage – ‘Not a Joke’

President Joe Biden said Tuesday on “CNN Tonight” that he will pass the assault weapon ban again before he leaves office.

Anchor Jake Tapper said, “Democratic voters approve of the job you’re doing. Democratic voters overwhelmingly like you. But one poll shows that almost two-thirds of Democratic voters want a new nominee in 2024, and the top reason they gave was your age. So what’s your message to Democrats who like you, who like what you’ve done but are concerned about your age and the demands of the job?”

Biden said, “They’re concerned whether or not I can get anything done. Name me a president in recent history that’s gotten as much done as I have in the first two years. Not a joke. The vast majority of the American people do like what I got done. And so it’s a matter of can you do the job, and I believe I can do the job. I’ve been able to do the job. I got more done. I got all this legislation passed. I ran on that. I said this is what I’m going to do, and I’m still getting it done. You know, dealing with, you know, making sure the veterans get compensated for the burn pits, making sure we’re in a situation where we finally have action on guns. By the way, I’m going to get an assault weapons ban before this is over. I’m going to get that again, not a joke.”

Keep reading