Going back at least to the first election of President Trump, schools have threatened to punish conservative students for recording their teachers’ alleged ideological indoctrination in the classroom, part of a broader educational push to ban recording that may expose staff misconduct or viewpoint discrimination in class.
Legal threats and denunciation in local media prompted California’s Orange Coast College to rescind its suspension of a student for documenting his professor’s diatribe against Trump’s 2016 election as an “act of terrorism,” birthing a larger student movement for accountability in the community college district and legislation to protect student whistleblowers.
Up the Pacific coast a decade later, under a different legal system, a high school student is going to court to overturn his suspension for publicly criticizing his school’s lessons on the legacy of Canada’s indigenous residential school system – comparable in sensitivity to the U.S. legacy of Jim Crow – and refusing to take down videos with classroom recordings.
The Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms is funding legal representation for 16-year-old Isaac Simpson, whose Coquitlam, British Columbia, school allegedly escalated his five-day suspension to a permanent ban in response to his second video publicizing his suspension based on the first video, which included recordings from a school assembly and his classroom.
Simpson’s high school initially said he could return “only if he removed the video or edited out all audio, footage and images of students, staff, visitors, and educational activities within the school,” JCCF said, citing an Oct. 8 letter from the principal.
The letter accused him of non-consensual recording and breaking “rules governing personal devices” – JCCF claims the former is “not inherently unlawful in Canada” – but also harassing others through “commentary that mocked others,” JCCF paraphrased, violating his Charter rights of freedom of expression in public school.
‘Is it worse to indoctrinate generations of students’ or film it?
The second video includes audio of Simpson’s fruitless pursuit of “right-wing” books in a school library, his “one-on-one interrogation” by the principal – redubbed to sound like Mickey Mouse – and a parent-teacher conference about Simpson’s video, plus the district’s promotion of a student’s video from an assembly without purportedly getting individual consent.
“Is it worse to indoctrinate generations of students or is it worse to film the indoctrinating of those students?” Simpson asks rhetorically in the parent-teacher conference.
The principal referred Simpson to the Student Suspension Review Committee of School District No. 43, about an hour east of Vancouver, when he refused to delete the videos, explicitly faulting Simpson’s viewpoint as well as rule violations, JCCF said.
The committee took one day to determine that refusing to remove the videos violates district policies and “negatively affected the school environment,” and will give Simpson “educational programming” at another school only if he removes both videos, JCCF said.
“This case raises serious questions about whether the school’s response went further than necessary and punished a student for challenging ideas promoted at school,” said Simpson’s lawyer, Elsa Michel. All citizens, especially students and their parents, “have a constitutional right to comment” on the content and form of public school curricula.