New York City has become the latest US jurisdiction to ban “surveillance pricing” – the practice of using personal data to set prices.
The Big Apple is by no means alone in this: similar bans have been enacted in Seattle, and in the states of Maryland, Connecticut, and New Jersey.
While New York City Council’s November 12 vote is a clear win for privacy and consumer rights, the bill still has to be signed into law by the mayor, and it will take a year after that to come into force.
Meanwhile, the definition of “surveillance pricing” in the bill is that it is pricing “set completely or in part by an algorithm that uses personal data to offer different prices to different customers for the same goods or services.”
Personal data is defined as “any data that identifies or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with a specific consumer or device.”
The bill’s sponsor, Speaker Julie Menin, has no doubt that this is harmful, and said in a memo that it means setting individualized prices based on “personal data collected about consumers’ characteristics and behaviors, like location, demographics, browsing patterns and shopping history.”
According to Menin, “when corporations use algorithms and personal data to charge different people different prices for the same products, it’s unethical and worsens our affordability crisis.”
The council also gave examples of how this works in real life, such as a grocery delivery platform experimenting with prices, with some customers seeing them “as high as 23 percent” different, while another example shows a TV’s price going up from $499.99 to $599.99 as soon as a customer pulls into the store’s parking lot.
Menin’s memo also states that it is “viscerally offensive to consumers to think about the fact that they are being basically sized up for their willingness to pay more” – and that is a quote from George Slover, of the Center for Democracy and Technology.
The bill also seeks to prevent anyone from collecting, selling, retaining or disclosing personal data “for the purpose of facilitating surveillance pricing.”
The bill does make exceptions for what it calls “bona fide discounts” that are not based on personal data, such as bulk or subscription deals, end-of-season and flash sales, inventory-based pricing, price matching, and rebates.
Another exception is “bona fide custom discounts” that a shopper is aware of, such as those received because of membership or loyalty programs, or based on purchase history.
However, Consumer Reports warned that even this rule is not absolute, as retailers can still use location data to charge more in neighborhoods with fewer stores. And purchase history, the group said, “can be used to profile shoppers and infer information about their family, income, and lifestyle.”
These exceptions were not removed from the bill, despite the warnings.
The council also carved out an exception for location data that a shopper shares with a business, allowing the latter to use it to calculate trip duration and mileage costs, as well as “to assess current or historical local supply and demand conditions” or for “aggregating local marketplace conditions.”
The ban also does not apply to securities broker-dealers and registered investment advisers, who can use “assets under management, account characteristics, or the customer relationship” to set prices.