Sometimes we read something so stunning that we would like it to somehow stand in the air, or be republished every week, so we could read it a bit at a time, as if it would not get old or be washed away down the inevitable line of time.
First stated in 2020, aptly enough, and repeated last week in the Sceptic, what I am going to call the Betz-Rainsborough hypothesis is so bold and paradoxical that I think it needs to be named, credited to them, and stated in emphatic form:
- Modern Western politics is emphatically and avowedly anti-imperial and post-colonial.
- However, by the greatest political irony of our time, modern Western states are imperial and colonial.
Explanation.
- The imperial and colonial rule is not over anyone else. It is over ourselves.
- The rulers of our states are determined no longer allow the citizens of the nation to rule themselves through their political institutions.
- Rather, they attempt to rule us imperially, according to a modern protocol of divide and rule, by which we are divided into ‘communities’ and coerced into acceptable behavior by ideology, incentive and government instrument.
- States, in short, in ruling their own citizens imperially and colonially, have made us into subjects.
This is a good example of a political irony. Indeed, it is an example of something that is probably as old as politics itself. The Betz-Rainsborough Hypothesis is a special case of the particular form of political irony that we should call Morley’s Law. I have quoted John Morley, Recollections (London: Macmillan, 1917), Vol. I, p. 192, before, and I will quote it again, but here it is: “Most mistakes in politics came from flat and invincible disregard of the maxim that it is possible for the same thing to be and not to be.”
Morley’s Law of Politics, is, I take it:
In politics it is possible for the same thing to be and not to be.
And this is so for many reasons. E.g. 1) Time itself, before and after. E.g. 2) Disputes, for and against. (You must have seen Cameron saying “the UK’s problems had nothing to do with its exit from the EU” and Burnham replying “I think he is wrong… the evidence says otherwise”.) E.g. 3) Different strata at which things may make sense, above and below, structural imperatives and accidental causes. Etc. But the most fundamental reason is 4) that something is x but is said to be y. This is the Hermetic or Rhetorical or, simply, Two-Faced, Fork-Tongued aspect of politics. We say one thing and do another.
(Remember also – something else that I think we all should repeat until we cannot forget it – that Prudentia, the great goddess of prudence, the goddess of the chief virtue of politics, has two faces.)
I like to say that Augustus was the first exponent of this sort of politics, when he said he restored the republic but actually established a monarchy. (The exquisite detail was that no Roman could call himself a king, rex, ever since the rape of Lucrece, so Augustus became a rex by pretending to be anything but a rex. He claimed consular powers, tribunician powers, pontifical powers, even said he gave all his powers back to the senate. Thus he avoided the fate of Julius Caesar, and launched on us the Roman emperordom.) But, in fact, Thucydides noticed this phenomenon 400 years before when, in a passage about Pericles in his History – 2.65 to be exact – he said that, in Athens, “the government was a democracy in name but in reality rule by the first citizen”. We used to understand this sort of thing. One of my old professors, Quentin Skinner, laid great emphasis on paradiastole. I never understood it when I was a student. Some things need decades to become significant. But paradiastole was the rhetorical term of art for this trick, a term used by Quintilian and others in the first century AD, and then taken up by all manner of Renaissance humanists much later on, until it found its way into such books as Henry Peacham’s Garden of Eloquence in 1577. Everyone knew about it.
We should all know about paradiastole.
It is, simply, saying that something is x when it is actually y. Or vice versa.