The End Of Man: The Real Danger Isn’t Artificial Intelligence

“Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold.”

– W.B. Yeats, “The Second Coming”

We have been suffering through a veritable cascade of technological failures.

First came a massive Microsoft outage that disrupted Outlook and other online services around the globe.

Then came a nationwide ground stop that brought air travel across America to a standstill, disrupting thousands of flights and leaving travelers stranded.

Then major banks experienced problems with their online systems.

Then United Airlines grounded departing flights after yet another computer failure.

Then reports that the highly classified network that the National Security Agency uses for its internal communications had gone down.

Then Apple joined the growing list of technology giants experiencing widespread disruptions, with users reporting problems accessing iCloud, the App Store, Apple Music and other services.

One breakdown after another. Communications disrupted. Transportation paralyzed. Financial services interrupted. Sensitive information potentially at risk. Millions of Americans reminded just how dependent their daily lives have become on technologies they neither understand nor control.

This is what happens when technology goes haywire.

Or is it?

Speculation was quick to point the finger at artificial intelligence, especially in the wake of the nationwide airline shutdown.

After all, the Trump administration had only recently expanded the FAA’s new SMART artificial-intelligence system to air traffic control centers across the country.

The administration has also been aggressively promoting AI (or SI for Super Intelligence as Trump insists it be called) as the answer to everything from government inefficiency to national security, even as it pushes to reduce regulatory barriers and expand the use of automated systems.

Yet the Trump administration insists AI had nothing to do with the airline shutdown.

Instead, federal officials blamed the disruption on a malfunction involving aging air traffic control infrastructure, with problems arising as equipment was being replaced and communications systems updated.

Perhaps so.

Meanwhile, the FBI issued a report about another technological danger: autonomous AI hacking tools such as Artex AI that are being used to launch cyberattacks across the U.S. and globally and breach networks in under three hours.

But whether the culprit is artificial intelligence, cyberattackers, outdated equipment, poor planning, inadequate maintenance, human error or some combination of these factors, the larger problem remains.

Who is responsible when the technological systems upon which society depends begin to fail?

Who is accountable when government officials and corporate executives rush to embrace new technologies without ensuring that the safeguards, infrastructure and human oversight needed to manage them are in place?

And what happens when we become so dependent on technology – and so willing to surrender responsibility for managing it – that we can no longer distinguish between the failure of a machine and the failure of the human beings entrusted with its operation?

We’ve been asking the wrong question about artificial intelligence.

Maybe the real danger isn’t that machines might become smarter than human beings.

Maybe it’s the human hunger for power – and our willingness to surrender control to those who wield it.

Hollywood has spent decades warning us about machines that might someday become so intelligent, so independent and so powerful that they no longer need human beings.

In Stanley Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey, the seemingly infallible computer HAL 9000 turns against the astronauts who have entrusted their lives to its control. The machine, designed to serve humanity, becomes a threat to the very people it was created to assist.

Yet the more unsettling vision may come from an unlikely source: Pixar’s animated children’s film WALL-E. In WALL-E, humanity has abandoned an uninhabitable Earth and retreated to a massive spaceship where nearly every human need is anticipated and satisfied by machines.

People no longer walk. They no longer work. They barely notice the world around them. They are entertained, fed, transported and distracted by systems that make virtually every decision for them. They have become passive consumers of their own existence.

The machines haven’t needed to wage war against humanity. Human beings have largely surrendered their independence willingly, trading responsibility for convenience and freedom for comfort. Even the ship’s captain must struggle to reclaim his authority from an automated system programmed to maintain the status quo.

The distinction is telling.

In 2001, the nightmare is a machine that refuses to surrender control. In WALL-E, the nightmare is a humanity that has forgotten how to exercise it. Both films arrive at a troubling truth: technology becomes dangerous when human beings cease to exercise meaningful control over it.

And therein lies the problem: we have confused technological progress with human progress.

We have become extraordinarily adept at inventing machines capable of performing tasks that earlier generations could scarcely imagine.

We can split atoms, launch rockets into space, communicate instantaneously across continents, map the human genome, monitor populations from satellites and build computers capable of processing staggering amounts of information. Yet none of these technological achievements has necessarily made us wiser, more compassionate, more ethical or more capable of exercising restraint.

History demonstrates how readily human beings turn their greatest inventions into instruments of destruction, exploitation and control.

Consider the atomic bomb.

The discovery of nuclear fission opened the door to extraordinary scientific advances. It also made possible weapons capable of obliterating entire cities.

In August 1945, the United States dropped atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, killing tens of thousands of people immediately and many more in the aftermath.

The bombs did not decide to destroy those cities. Human beings did.

Keep reading

Unknown's avatar

Author: HP McLovincraft

Seeker of rabbit holes. Pessimist. Libertine. Contrarian. Your huckleberry. Possibly true tales of sanity-blasting horror also known as abject reality. Prepare yourself. Veteran of a thousand psychic wars. I have seen the fnords. Deplatformed on Tumblr and Twitter.

Leave a Reply