Man Convicted Of Abusing Boys Fights To Obtain Infant Son Born Through Paid Surrogacy

A 75-year-old former registered sex offender arranged to have a child via surrogacy and is now appealing a ruling denying him custody, exposing the many dangers of the commodification of pregnancy.

In November 2025, a male infant was born in Rockwall County, Texas. His biological father is Sanford S. Kaplan, who lives in Colorado. Kaplan had pleaded no contest in 2009 in Nebraska to seven counts of child abuse and one count of false imprisonment involving multiple adolescent boys and was sentenced to consecutive terms totaling up to 24 years. He had served roughly seven years in prison, completed parole in 2021, and (at the time) remained on the sex-offender registry. Contemporary news accounts described the offenses as involving binding, blindfolding, gagging, and suspending boys from rafters in a garage at his Lincoln home while he was a youth soccer coach.

Kaplan had arranged a gestational surrogacy with a young woman (“SM”). SM carried a child conceived with a donor egg and Kaplan’s sperm. The arrangement was formalized in a February 2025 agreement. In July 2025, the two jointly asked a Travis County district court to approve the agreement under Texas law and to skip the normal home-study requirement used to assess the intended parents’ home for the child’s safety. The court entered an order approving the arrangement in August 2025. This preliminary order declared Kaplan would “be the legal father” and would have the right to “immediate custody” of and access to the child “upon birth,” the right to name the child, and the right to make any and all health decisions regarding the child.

Only the intervention of the hospital where the birth was expected, followed by the Department of Family and Protective Services, stopped Kaplan from taking immediate custody once the baby was born in November. A jury later terminated his parental rights. Kaplan has appealed.

The case is a stark illustration of the risks inherent in commercial and quasi-commercial surrogacy arrangements — risks that advocacy groups such as Surrogacy Concern have long highlighted: the prioritization of adult desire over child welfare, the commodification of pregnancy, the enabling of single older men, and the structural incentives that discourage anyone in the transaction from raising red flags.

Keep reading

Unknown's avatar

Author: HP McLovincraft

Seeker of rabbit holes. Pessimist. Libertine. Contrarian. Your huckleberry. Possibly true tales of sanity-blasting horror also known as abject reality. Prepare yourself. Veteran of a thousand psychic wars. I have seen the fnords. Deplatformed on Tumblr and Twitter.

Leave a Reply