Texas Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa (D) is seeking to eliminate the state’s $1 billion school voucher program and reverse several education policies enacted under outgoing Republican Gov. Greg Abbott, despite warnings from national education researchers that dismantling certain reforms could undermine efforts to improve student achievement.
According to a November 18 report from the Marshall News Messenger, the Houston Chronicle interviewed eight national education researchers, most of whom cautioned against repealing or significantly restricting many of the education policies implemented during Abbott’s administration, including measures related to academic accountability and teacher compensation. Researchers offered mixed assessments of state intervention in struggling school districts.
“What’s making people nervous, I think, is whether that commitment to student outcomes is going to stay,” Marguerite Roza, director of Georgetown University’s Edunomics Lab, told the Chronicle.
Hinojosa has pledged to pause Texas’s A-F school accountability ratings, which evaluate the academic performance of schools and districts, although existing state law appears to prevent her from doing so.
Lori Taylor, a Texas A&M University professor, acknowledged flaws in the grading methodology but emphasized the importance of measuring student achievement.
“You can’t cure the patient if you’re taking away the thermometers,” Taylor said. “You have to have some measure of achievement.”
Hinojosa has also called for ending the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness (STAAR), the annual standardized testing system used to evaluate students. Although Texas lawmakers passed legislation last year to replace the tests, Hinojosa opposed that replacement and has said she wants a “fairer” assessment system without specifying precisely how it would operate.
“I think that it would be a major mistake to substantially uproot statewide testing without a clear plan of how we are going to efficiently and accurately assess what students know and are able to do,” Matthew Kraft, an education professor at Brown University, told the Chronicle.
Researchers also praised the Teacher Incentive Allotment, an Abbott-backed initiative that provides funding to increase compensation for effective and high-performing teachers, with additional incentives for educators working in schools serving lower-income communities.
Texas Tech University professor Jacob Kirksey, who has studied the initiative, pointed to its results in participating school districts.
“It’s improved student achievement statewide for those participating districts,” Kirksey said.
Hinojosa, however, has advocated broader teacher raises rather than tying compensation to student performance.
“We need teacher compensation, real teacher compensation, not just more money into a performance pay program that requires our teachers jump through more hoops to get more pay,” Hinojosa told the Chronicle. “Teachers do a lot. Teachers do too much, actually.”
The governor-elect has also pledged to end state takeovers of struggling school districts. Under existing Texas law, the state must assume control of a district or close a failing school when a campus receives five consecutive failing accountability ratings.
Morath has described the state’s 2023 takeover of Houston Independent School District as one of the greatest turnarounds in American history, citing an increase from 39 percent to 51 percent in the share of the district’s approximately 170,000 students meeting grade-level expectations in reading and mathematics.
Researchers said the district’s emphasis on struggling schools and higher teacher compensation appeared to be producing improvements, although it remains too early to draw definitive conclusions about the intervention’s effectiveness.
Some Houston-area Democrat lawmakers, including incoming Texas House Speaker Senfronia Thompson, have also acknowledged improvements in schools following the takeover.