Donald Trump and his administration have done a grave disservice to America’s military. By politicizing the military, sending service members into wars of questionable legality, attempting to use military forces against American citizens, and seeking to punish veterans who exercise their constitutional rights, the Trump administration has attempted to turn the U.S. military into its own guns-for-hire battalion.
This is not how you honor America’s military.
Pete Hegseth has done an even graver disservice to the men and women who serve.
Having called for a “warrior ethos” that celebrates aggression, lethality and an unquestioning commitment to warfighting, the self-styled Secretary of War has repeatedly demonstrated a troubling disregard for the constitutional safeguards meant to govern the military’s use of force.
Consider his record.
Hegseth fired the military’s top uniformed lawyers—the very officers charged with ensuring that military operations and orders comply with the law—complaining that legal advisers should not become “roadblocks.”
He shared sensitive operational details about impending military strikes in Yemen over an unauthorized Signal chat, exposing military personnel and missions to potential danger. The Pentagon’s own inspector general subsequently found that he had violated departmental security protocols.
He imposed sweeping restrictions on Pentagon journalists, limiting independent scrutiny of military operations and prompting a federal court to find that the department’s press restrictions violated the First Amendment.
He sought to punish retired Navy captain and Senator Mark Kelly for reminding service members of their duty to refuse unlawful orders, threatening his military rank and retirement pay until a federal judge intervened.
He has used the Pentagon to promote his particular brand of Christianity, hosting Christian worship services, inviting a Christian nationalist preacher into the halls of military power, and overhauling the military’s chaplaincy system in ways that have raised serious concerns about the religious freedom of service members who do not share his beliefs.
He has invoked the Crusades as a model of religious struggle, defended the Christian warriors who fought them, and called for pushing back against “Islamism” culturally, politically, geographically and militarily. Even as American troops wage war against Iran, Hegseth has invoked biblical warfare and prayed at a Pentagon service for overwhelming force against enemies he described as deserving “no mercy.”
And he has overseen military operations in Iran, Yemen and the Caribbean that have raised serious questions about congressional war powers, civilian casualties and the legality of deadly force—including so-called “kinetic” strikes on suspected drug-smuggling vessels that have prompted allegations of war crimesand demands for legal accountability.
Now, faced with eight articles of impeachment introduced by Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Kentucky), Hegseth has dismissed the effort as an act of “sabotage,” suggesting that holding military leaders accountable amounts to punishing the troops who carry out their orders.
Questioning the war makers is not an attack on the troops. It is one way of defending them.
The charges at the heart of Massie’s impeachment effort speak to an identity crisis under Hegseth’s leadership—one that pits the Founders’ vision of a military that exists to defend the Constitution and a constitutional form of government against a version of the military as a ruthless killing machine whose purpose is to invade, intimidate, and destroy the president’s enemies.
America’s service members represent different religions, political beliefs and walks of life, but they are bound by a common oath: to support and defend the Constitution.