Should a millionaire qualify for food stamps traditionally reserved for Americans with low incomes? Common sense says “of course not.” But for years, affluent individuals can and have qualified for these benefits. Thankfully, a recent proposal from the Trump administration looks to change that.
The rule, if finalized as written, would eliminate a gimmick called “broad-based categorical eligibility” that most states use to expand who qualifies for food stamps. It’s another example of the constant fight against waste, fraud, and abuse within government.
Unilateral Eligibility Expansion
The proposed rule issued by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) seeks to codify a similar series of reforms to those that the first Trump administration proposed, but could not finalize, before the incoming Biden administration withdrew them. They would reverse Obama-era changes that increased the number of people receiving Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits, also known as food stamps.
As the rule’s preamble explains, Congress in the 1980s created categorical eligibility as a way to eliminate duplicative paperwork burdens on low-income households that qualified for both food stamps and cash welfare benefits. But since then, Congress in 1996 passed historic welfare reform legislation, which dramatically shrank the number of families who qualified for cash benefits, while increasing other non-cash forms of assistance.
In many cases, these non-cash forms of assistance have different and/or higher limits on income and assets than the food stamp program itself. As implemented, then, categorical eligibility expands the number of households qualifying for food stamp benefits beyond the program’s statutory guidelines.
Obama-Era Benefits Explosion
A September 2009 USDA memo illustrates how the Obama administration turned “increasing SNAP participation” into a policy and political strategy. The memo specifically noted that households could become “categorically eligible for SNAP because they receive a non-cash … benefit or service, such as an informational pamphlet or 800-number.” Through this expanded loophole, anyone who “benefited” from receiving a pamphlet could qualify for food stamps, no matter the assets they held.
And some food stamp recipients did hold major assets, including multiple lottery winners. A Wall Street Journal article described a Detroit resident who defended her receipt of monthly SNAP benefits despite winning $1 million the previous year: “I feel that it’s OK because I have no income … and I have bills to pay. I have two houses.”
In another case from Michigan described in the Journal, a recipient called a state agency and asked whether his $850,000 in lottery winnings the prior year made him ineligible for benefits. Shockingly — but sadly not surprisingly — state bureaucrats told him he could remain on food stamps. Perhaps this is what the Obama administration meant when it wrote that “adopting expanded categorical eligibility can promote asset accumulation among low-income families.”