Miami Sheriff Hired a Private Law Firm To Pursue—and Profit From—Asset Forfeiture Cases

A court appeal challenging the Miami-Dade County sheriff’s unusual practice of using a private law firm to pursue property seizures on its behalf—and guaranteeing the firm a cut of the proceeds—could change the law surrounding police seizures in Florida and is drawing national attention from think tanks and criminal defense groups.

The appeal, brought by a group of Miami-area mobile phone distributors and retailers who had tens of millions of dollars seized by the Miami-Dade County Sheriff’s Office (MDSO) last year, is the first time Florida state courts have considered whether police departments can pay private law firms on a contingency basis to represent them in civil asset forfeiture cases.

Under civil forfeiture laws, police can seize property suspected of being connected to criminal activity, even when the owner hasn’t been charged with a crime. Several states effectively abolished civil forfeiture in recent years after decades of complaints from civil liberties groups that property owners lacked due process protections.

The electronics businesses allege the MDSO violated their due process rights when it hired a private law firm to pursue civil forfeiture cases against them, and they’re asking a state appeals court, in a brief filed in October, to recognize that it’s unconstitutional to be “prosecuted by counsel who stands to profit immensely from whatever property counsel succeeds in forfeiting.”

Lisandra Guerrero, one of the attorneys for the businesses, said in statement to Reason that “the public interest pays the price when the sheriff puts forfeiture prosecutions on commission, paying a lawyer a cut of every dollar forfeited.”

“Would we accept a police officer collecting a percentage of every traffic ticket he writes?” Guerrero continued. “Of course not. His job is to enforce the law, not to make money at the expense of citizens. So why allow it when it comes to lawyers with the power to seize property?”

The MDSO argued in court that it maintains oversight of which cases to file and settle, but a variety of interest groups have also submitted amicus briefs in the case arguing that this sort of bounty arrangement violates a bedrock legal principle of evenhandedness and neutrality that is supposed to ethically bind judges and prosecutors.

“The problem is that it incentivizes a private attorney to create litigation, not to go after those who have done the worst crimes, but those who have the deepest pocketbooks or who are most vulnerable to having their property taken,” says Tim Sandefur, the vice president for legal affairs at the Goldwater Institute, a free market think tank that filed an amicus brief on behalf of the Miami businesses challenging the practice.

The dispute started last August, when the MDSO seized $45 million from 16 Miami-area mobile phone businesses and froze their bank accounts. The majority of that money, $42.7 million, belonged to SH Americas, which claims in court filings to be the largest authorized distributor of Samsung devices in South Florida. The seizures were part of a sprawling investigation into an alleged money laundering scheme run by two Chinese nationals. However, those forfeiture cases weren’t handled by the MDSO’s legal counsel or the state attorney’s office, but instead by the Coral Gables law firm of Israel Reyes, a former police detective, prosecutor, and judge. (In January of 2025, Reyes swore in current Miami-Dade Sheriff Rosie Cordero-Stutz.)

Keep reading

Unknown's avatar

Author: HP McLovincraft

Seeker of rabbit holes. Pessimist. Libertine. Contrarian. Your huckleberry. Possibly true tales of sanity-blasting horror also known as abject reality. Prepare yourself. Veteran of a thousand psychic wars. I have seen the fnords. Deplatformed on Tumblr and Twitter.

Leave a Reply