Challenging New York Over Its Mandatory Social Media Warnings

Every day, millions of New Yorkers access social media to read the news, check in on friends, watch a lecture, attend a religious service, debate politics, learn something new, or share a photograph.

Starting January 1, 2027, they will all be interrupted by a message from the state of New York, lasting at least ten seconds, thanks to a law that is now being challenged in court by NetChoice, a trade group.

The law, Senate Bill 4505, amended by Senate Bill 8827, was signed by Governor Kathy Hochul in December 2025, and the attorney general, Letitia James, is now being sued in a federal court in Manhattan to stop it from taking effect.

The law says that social media companies must show a warning label, written by the state, that users cannot skip. The only way to avoid it is if the platform has “reasonably determined that the user is over seventeen years of age.” But the law does not say how this is to be done, and the attorney general is yet to come up with rules on that.

The complaint mentions that the attorney general is authorized to come up with rules and regulations to enforce the law, but notes that the law itself does not provide any guidance on how to implement the age exemption.

This is a crucial point, because the warning is shown to all users by default – and the only way to avoid it is to prove to the platform that you are over 17. But how platforms are to determine this is left unexplained, and the attorney general is yet to come up with rules.

However, it is not hard to figure out what the “guidance” will be, given that the New York government already has a law in place, the SAFE for Kids Act, that is due to come into force on January 25, 2027. And that law defines “age assurance” as “any type of age estimation, age inference, or age verification.”

In other words, the warning that the state is about to start forcing social media to show to their users will likely require those users to verify their age if they want to be able to use the platforms without interruptions. And the way to do that will be either to show government-issued ID, or use some other method, such as “zero-knowledge proof” – a cryptographic technique that proves something is true without revealing the information itself.

In July, when the SAFE for Kids rules were announced, the attorney general was asked if they raised privacy concerns, and replied, “not a question of privacy.”

The SAFE for Kids Act is not the only one that contains a reference to age verification. S.9051-B, a law that regulates the use of chatbots, and was signed on October 28, says that platforms can offer full features of their chatbots only if they “used methods that are permissible under article forty-five” – that is, the same methods spelled out in the SAFE for Kids Act.

In other words, the chatbot law lets platforms offer full features only to users whose age has been checked.

Keep reading

Unknown's avatar

Author: HP McLovincraft

Seeker of rabbit holes. Pessimist. Libertine. Contrarian. Your huckleberry. Possibly true tales of sanity-blasting horror also known as abject reality. Prepare yourself. Veteran of a thousand psychic wars. I have seen the fnords. Deplatformed on Tumblr and Twitter.

Leave a Reply