The debate over Flock cameras has brought a familiar tension between safety and freedom to American communities. Flock Safety—a supplier of automated license-plate readers (ALPRs)—says its technology “helps communities deter crime, respond to emergencies, and investigate safety incidents.” Critics argue that this surveillance threatens Fourth Amendment protections.
Meanwhile, the Institute for Justice has cataloged more than 200 reported incidents of abuse and misuse involving ALPR systems, including stalking, wrongful stops and detentions, and searches unrelated to law enforcement. These cases illustrate what can happen when officials gain access to detailed records of people’s movements, including those suspected of no wrongdoing.
However, Flock Safety is responding to an ambiance that the government itself has cultivated. Its business reflects a political environment shaped by twenty-five years of expanding Big Brother’s influence across the nation.
Tyranny Comes Home
After September 11, the 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force (or the AUMF) authorized force against those responsible for the attacks and those who harbored them. The PATRIOT Act—enacted the following month—expanded surveillance, information sharing, and financial monitoring. The war on terrorism, a war on a noun, offered no clear endpoint: defeating one organization could not eliminate terrorism itself. In Tyranny Comes Home, Christopher Coyne and Abigail Hall describe the boomerang effect of how government powers and practices developed abroad can return to erode liberty at home.
By 2013, Washington had fought wars in Afghanistan and Iraq and intervened in Libya in 2011. In 2013, Edward Snowden’s disclosures revealed how foreign intelligence collection also reached Americans. Through the NSA’s PRISM program, operating under Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, the government obtained communications from service providers while targeting non-US persons reasonably believed to be abroad. Americans could have their messages collected and subsequently searched without themselves being suspected of wrongdoing. In other words, the foreign intelligence mission had created a resource for government scrutiny at home and abroad.
Financial scrutiny also expanded through tax enforcement, reaching Americans living abroad. In July 2014, key foreign-bank provisions of the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) began taking effect. Enacted in 2010, the law required participating institutions to report information about US accounts, directly or through their governments. American citizens remain subject to US tax rules on worldwide income, federal reporting obligations can follow them even when their work, savings, and daily lives are abroad.
Federal scrutiny could follow Americans through their travels as well as their finances. In 2018, air marshal whistleblowers helped expose the TSA’s Quiet Skies program. Marshals secretly followed travelers who were neither under investigation nor on the terrorist watchlist, recording ordinary behavior such as sleeping or using the bathroom. The same agency Americans knew for checking shoes and liquids at airport checkpoints was gathering intelligence on passengers beyond them.
Moreover, a 2020 inspector general report found that TSA lacked the performance measures needed to demonstrate Quiet Skies’ effectiveness. The program then needed another 5 years before being discontinued in 2025. It is just one example where TSA, time and time again, has failed while racking up the bill to the tune of $10 billion a year. The security theater illustrates how the promise of security can justify intrusive powers long before any public benefits appear, if at all.
These policies carried costs in public spending as well as individual liberty. What did Americans receive in return?