“Being a parent is a privilege not a right: the only right which matters is a child’s right to safety.” Those were the words of a Justice Minister, Baroness Levitt KC, when the Government announced in October 2025 that it would change the law for separated families. Claire Fox – Baroness Fox of Buckley – told the House of Lords that she was “brought up short” by them. “Surely a privilege is something that the state grants and can take away. Is the state saying that it owns parents’ rights? Actually, parents do have rights.”
Baroness Levitt’s thinking lies behind a change now before the House of Lords. In its Courts and Tribunals Bill, the Government wants to remove from the law the presumption that, when parents separate, their children are better off with both of them still involved in their lives. Clause 16 would abolish that important, child-centred default presumption. Lord Farmer has warned that removing the presumption will “have lifelong negative effects for children when safe parents are excluded from their lives”.
The House of Lords committee stage began on Tuesday November 10th and resumes today. Lord Keen of Elie and Lord Wolfson of Tredegar have given notice that they’ll seek to strike out clause 16.
Opening the debate at second reading on October 27th, the Minister, Lord Lemos, said the Bill will repeal the presumption, “ensuring that children’s safety and welfare continue to be the foremost concern of the courts”. His own word, “continue”, concedes that the courts already put children first. The Children Act 1989 makes the child’s welfare “the court’s paramount consideration”. The presumption serves that principle. All it presumes is that, where a parent can be involved safely, their involvement “will further the child’s welfare”. So what would the repeal add?
In court, very little. The Government’s own papers concede that the presumption already “does not apply where there is a risk of harm”. They also concede that repeal alone is “unlikely to materially change outcomes”. On October 20th a Justice Minister, Jake Richards, told MPs: “The courts are already empowered to restrict or prevent contact.”