Police can traipse onto the vast majority of private property in the country without a warrant thanks to a century-old Supreme Court decision, according to a new study by the Institute for Justice, a libertarian-leaning public-interest law firm.
In a study published in the spring 2024 issue of Regulation, a publication of the Cato Institute, Institute for Justice attorney Josh Windham and research analyst David Warren estimate that at least 96 percent of all private land in the country is excluded from Fourth Amendment’s warrant requirement under the “open-fields doctrine,” which allows police to forego warrants when they searched fields, woods, vacant lots, and other property not near a dwelling.
That adds up to nearly 1.2 billion acres open to government trespass, and the Institute for Justice says that’s a conservative estimate. The organization also says the study is the first attempt to quantify how much private property is affected by the Supreme Court’s 1924 ruling in Hester v. U.S., which created the doctrine.
“Now we have hard data showing that the Supreme Court’s century-old error blew a massive hole in Americans’ property and privacy rights,” Windham said in a press release. “Now we know what the open fields doctrine really means: Government officials can treat almost all private land in this country like public property.”
Windham added that “courts and lawmakers across the country will have to face the consequences of keeping this doctrine on the books.”
Hellbound and Down 